05/07/2017 ~ Fourth Sunday of Easter ~ *Acts 2:42-47; Psalm 23; 1 Peter 2:19-25; John 10:1-10 ~ Communion Sunday.
They Did Not Understand
“Jesus used this figure of speech, this metaphor with the disciples. But they did not grasp, they did not understand what Jesus was trying to say to them.” — John 10:6.
As you may know, we have Christian Education sessions on Sunday mornings and Wednesday evenings. On Sundays our young folks go upstairs to the Christian Education area and are under the tutelage of Linda Oehme.
Those a little longer in tooth have to endure a session with me. The braver souls among them also visit with me for a different session on Wednesday evenings.
Last year on Sunday mornings those of us of that certain age watched a series of undergraduate lectures in the Hebrew Scriptures given by Professor Christine Hayes of Yale University. These lectures are out there on the internet and they are free. Anyone can watch.
These lectures are a 101, basic level, college course. I suspect many first year students take the course thinking passing it is a piece of cake. They are wrong.
Now, since it is a given this class will have people with many views about the Bible, in the first lecture Professor Hayes lays out the purpose of the course, which is not to change the beliefs people have. Rather, the purpose is to invite students to analyze what is to be found in Scripture and to think deeply about what is found. While that kind of work has the potential to change thinking, it is not the object of the class.
Well, during the first lecture Hayes states she has two daughters one is a teen and one is verging on her teen years. Professor Hayes— a Biblical Scholar— then says she does not let these two young ladies read the Bible.
What is in the Bible, she says, the text, is clearly adult reading. Among other issues, it contains violence of all kinds— economic violence, physical violence, misconduct, abuse. This is not appropriate reading for children. (Slight pause.)
That brings up this concept of Sola Scriptura— Scripture alone. One could say this a tenet of the Protestant Reformation. Sola Scriptura holds Scripture is the sole rule of faith and practice, one of the main theological points raised by Martin Luther.
Indeed, Luther translated the Bible into the vernacular. For Luther the vernacular was German. This helped Scripture be more accessible for many, at least for those who read German.
However, one of the things we do not realize about the era in which the Protestant Reformation happened is literacy rates were low. Among adult males the rate in the 1500s ran about 20%. Among women it was lower. Hence, even in a vernacular translation, those who read Scripture were among the few and were fairly well educated.
In fact, when Scripture was read from the pulpit in the church served by Calvin in Geneva— and Calvin was in the next generation of reformers after Luther— when was read from the pulpit in the church served by Calvin in Geneva it would be read in the original languages— Hebrew and Greek. A translation would not be read.
An assumption was being made that all those in the pews listening understood those original languages. These were highly educated people. (Slight pause.)
When I talk to people about how to read Scripture I always say you should never read Scripture without a commentary right next to you. I never read Scripture without a commentary right next to me.
Do I know more about Scripture than the average bear? Probably. Even though I have a Master of Divinity Degree, I do not presume I know what a passage means simply by reading it. At best, that would be ego-centric. So I consult commentaries.
To be clear, I am not saying you should avoid reading Scripture. You should read Scripture; we all should read Scripture. Reading Scripture should be a part of our daily prayer and practice. I am simply saying to read it without bringing some understanding beyond one’s own grasp of what’s there is simply unwise.
You see, the last time I looked the Bible is not Aladdin’s lamp. And God is not some kind of genie who grants wishes based on what you think the words say, especially since the words we read are a translation from ancient languages.
To treat Scripture and the reading thereof as if it is a simply a straightforward process is akin to treating God as a genie and Scripture as the lamp you rub. And that is a very, very, very secular way of looking at Scripture. (Slight pause.)
We find these words in the Gospel according to the School of John: “Jesus used this figure of speech, this metaphor with the disciples. But they did not grasp, they did not understand what Jesus was trying to say to them.” (Slight pause.)
The Hebrew Scriptures— which by the way, that’s the only Bible Jesus knew— the Hebrew Scriptures have many images of God as a shepherd. Hence, the question which immediately comes to mind for me is why do those who listen have a hard time grasping the shepherd metaphor. Indeed, the next sentence after today’s assigned reading says (quote): “I am the good shepherd.” (Slight pause.)
Let’s explore this a little. We find a number of “I am” statements in John. The “I am” statements are found only in John, one of the things which sets this Gospel apart from the Synoptic Gospels. But the question still remains: ‘why are those who listen confused?’ (Slight pause.)
I want to suggest one reason those who listen to Jesus might be confused has to do with the object of all the “I am” statements. And for the record, these statements are I am ‘the gate,’ ‘the bread of life,’ ‘the light of the world,’ ‘the door,’ ‘the good shepherd,’ ‘the resurrection,’ ‘the life,’ ‘the way,’ ‘the truth’ and ‘the vine.’ In each of these the object of the statements are not the point being made by this Gospel.
The important part of these statements is “I am.” “I am,” as you probably know, is, effectively, the name of God. I want to suggest those who listened to Jesus both understood this but did not want to understand this.
You see, for a good Jew in New Testament times the issue was not that Jesus might be the Messiah. Any Jew could have processed that. For a good Jew in New Testament times the issue was how was one to connect God and the Messiah?
And that’s where the “I am” statements become difficult in this era, in this place. As to why any Jew would have trouble with the “I am” statements, Jews maintained that there is one God and that God is one.
And even if you argue the “I am” statements did not clearly equate God and Jesus, the “I am” statements imply an equivalency. For a good Jew in New Testament times to draw an equivalency between God and anyone was heresy.
Indeed, in the Gospel we commonly call John, Jesus is consistently pictured as being divine. And even if you argue this was not a heresy for a good Jew in New Testament times— if you make that argument— it certainly came right up to the line that would make folks really nervous. (Slight pause.)
All that brings me back to the thought that we might need a commentary near us when we read Scripture. Why. Why? We have our own modern heresy.
We tend to treat Scripture, we treat what is commonly referred to as the Word of God, this collection of canonized books... like it is God. The Bible is... not... God. (Slight pause.)
Now, my bet is some of you are thinking the argument I’m presenting is an argument that effectively says Scripture needs to be studied and, therefore, Scripture is only accessible to academics or people who are in some way elite. And how can that be? After all, we are not all academics and God does not favor the elite! (Slight pause.)
I need to make a distinction. Scripture is not faith, itself. And more to the point, just as Scripture is not God, Scripture is not faith in God. We should not treat Scripture like it is God or treat Scripture like it is faith in God. That is when and where we get lost— when we treat Scripture like it’s God or treat Scripture like it’s faith in God. (Slight pause.)
Now, this poses yet another interesting question: what is the practice of faith about? Is the practice of faith simply about what we find in Scripture? Or is the practice of faith about us living in our time, knowing and believing in God, Who is in our world and relating to our world? (Slight pause.)
A famous Biblical scholar of the 20th Century, Rabbi Abraham Heschel, said this: “God is hiding in the world. Our task is to let the divine emerge from our deeds.”
And indeed, our task is to seek the will of God in our world and to act on the will of God. And that is what real faith is about and that is what faith is really about.
Can we learn about God from Scripture? Yes. But I think we can learn a lot about God by being faithful and striving to do the will of God in this, God’s world.
Or as I said at the end of my comments last week, the God of Covenant is a God of forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love. If we are faithful and have faith in the God of Covenant, we can come to a real understanding of what Scripture actually says rather than what we think it might say.
Why? How can we come to that understanding? Forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love are not just central to Who God is. Forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love should jump out at us from every page of Scripture when we do understand Who God is. Amen.
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York.
05/07/2017
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “A quote that has been attributed to many people says we need to have the Bible in one hand and a newspaper in the other. It does not matter who said it. The point is when we deal with the world around us, the real world, we need to reflect the forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love of God.”
BENEDICTION: Let us rejoice for Christ is risen. This service of worship is over but our service in the name of God continues outside these doors. And may we love God so much, that we love nothing else too much. May we be so in awe of God that we are in awe of no one else and nothing else. Amen.
Sunday, May 7, 2017
Sunday, April 30, 2017
SERMON ~ 04/30/2017 ~ “Explaining Scripture”
04/30/2017 ~ Third Sunday of Easter ~ *Acts 2:14a, 36-41; Psalm 116:1-4, 12-19; 1 Peter 1:17-23; Luke 24:13-35.
Explaining Scripture
“They said to each other, ‘Were not our hearts burning within us while Jesus was talking to us on the road, explaining the Scripture to us?’” — Luke 24:32.
In my first year as pastor here I was asked this question: “When we recite a creed in the service, I’ve noticed you always use the Nicene Creed. Why don’t you use the Apostles’ Creed?”
“Well,” I explained, “as far as anyone can tell, no Apostle had any hand in or even heard of the Apostles’ Creed. It was written a long, long time after the Apostles were alive and actually a long, long time after the Nicene Creed was composed.” (Slight pause.)
Let me unpack that a little. The earliest trace of anything called the Apostles’ Creed happened nearly 700 years after the Resurrection, sometime around the year 710 of the Common Era. Further, the first written trace of the Apostles’ Creed is found in what we today call France.
Now as to why the Apostles’ Creed spread and became popular, the Emperor Charlemagne had a significant impact on that. Charlemagne ruled the Holy Roman Empire, as it was called, from the year 800 to 814 of the Common Era. Despite the fact that it was only about 100 years old at that point— perhaps Charlemagne didn’t know that— the Emperor insisted the Apostles’ Creed be used throughout the Empire.
Thereby, the Apostles’ Creed became widely used in the West. That’s not a surprise since the Apostles’ Creed is a product of Europe, a product of the West. But it has never been used in liturgical practice in Eastern Orthodox Churches. And that’s not a surprise either since Eastern Orthodox Churches were largely outside of Charlemagne’s influence.
Now, as to why one might use the Nicene Creed rather than the Apostles’ Creed, the answer is simple given the history I just recited. And, to elaborate on the Nicene Creed a little, it was composed by a church council which met in the city of Nicaea in what is modern day Turkey.
This happened in the year 325 of the Common Era. It was the first unified Church Council ever and this creed is used in both the church in the East and the church in the West. Further, the Nicene Creed is the only Creed ever sanctioned by any council of the church. (Slight pause.)
So, why bring up all this about church creeds? Well, toward the end of today’s Gospel reading we hear a very interesting statement. The two travelers who have encountered Jesus return to where the disciples are gathered and hear these words: “Christ has risen! It is true! Jesus has appeared to Simon!” These words from Luke reflect what Paul writes about thirty years before Luke is composed.
And what Paul records is what some call the earliest Creed of the church because these words probably pre-date even Paul’s writings. Paul says Christ was (quote:) “...buried and..., on the third day, Christ was raised in accordance with the Scriptures and... was seen by Cephas— Peter...”— part of an early record in the writings of Paul and exactly what we hear in Luke. (Slight pause.)
We find these words in the work known as Luke: “They said to each other, ‘Were not our hearts burning within us while Jesus was talking to us on the road, explaining the Scripture to us?’” (Slight pause.)
I need to make an obvious statement. We live in the year 2017 of the Common Era. Sometimes that gets in our way when we try to understand stories which were written 2,000 years ago.
You see, when we hear the question, “Are you the only one visiting Jerusalem who does not know the things that have taken place there...?” our brains can play a little bit of a trick on us. One reaction might be ‘did this person not buy the newspaper and read the headlines that morning?’ As I am sure you realize, there were no newspapers.
Further, estimates of the population in Jerusalem run anywhere from a low of 20,000 to a high of more than 1,000,000. The most credible of these estimates run in the range of 100,000.
But this was also the Passover season, so it’s likely many, many pilgrims were in town because of that. So for sake of argument, let’s put the estimated population of Jerusalem this time at about 150,000.
My point is, especially with a population that large, news did not travel with any speed at all in ancient times. So, one might start to wonder why that question about ‘did you not hear what happened’ is even in this story.
That would not have spread. Why ask that question? You see, that someone might have heard this among a population this large in Biblical times just stretches credulity. And, therefore, one might, I certainly do, start to ask, “what is really going on here with this story?” or “What is this story getting at?”
I need follow all that up with yet another statement, but this one is less than obvious. The manuscript from which these words are taken depicts the village of Emmaus as being some seven miles from Jerusalem. Other ancient manuscripts say Emmaus is twenty miles out from Jerusalem.
However, Biblical historians have never been able to find any ancient town with the name Emmaus. Further, there does not even seem to be any hidden meaning it the name. Its likely meaning is “warm spring.” So the name is completely innocuous.
I think all this information again prompts me to ask questions like, “where is this story trying to lead us?” “What is it trying to tell us?”
Well, that’s when I turn to the phrase that says Jesus explained Scripture to these travelers. More specifically, what does it mean that Jesus explained Scripture (quote:) “...beginning with Moses and all the prophets,...”? (Slight pause.)
I need to make one more obvious statement. The only Scripture Jesus knew is what we call the Hebrew Scriptures, the Old Testament.
And for those who first heard or read this story, the words used here— ‘Moses and all the prophets’— would have had a very specific meaning. When the word Moses was used referring to Scripture in ancient times people took it to mean the Torah, the Pentateuch— the Book of Moses. Add the Prophets to that and what do you have? The only Scripture Jesus knew.
And what does the Torah and the Prophets— the Hebrew Scripture— the only Scripture Jesus knew, say? The Hebrew Scripture insists God loves us and God wants to be in covenant with us. (Slight pause.)
Now I suppose you have noticed over time that I often speak about the covenant of God. Why would I concentrate on covenant so much? Well here’s one thing. Scholars tell us there are at least 12 signs of the covenant in the Hebrew Scripture— signs of the covenant with Noah, with Abraham, with Moses, with David, with the Priests.
And again, what does that covenant in Hebrew Scripture say? It says God loves us and wants to be in covenant with us. That is what the Hebrew Scripture— the only Bible Jesus knew— is about. That’s it; that’s all; case closed— covenant. (Slight pause.)
Now, I can hear the skeptical among you say what Jesus explained had to do with the Messiah. And that is not about covenant. My take on this is simple. The resurrected Jesus is yet another a sign of the covenant.
Why do I say the resurrected Jesus is a sign of the covenant? Here’s one reason right from this reading. (Quote:) “Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it and gave it to them.”
When we celebrate Communion still today the words we use insist the meal is a sign of the covenant. (Quote:) “This cup is the new covenant— the new covenant.” (Slight pause.)
All that brings me back to statements of faith, what we commonly called creeds. I maintain statements of faith are not a list of what we believe, although many people take them that way. Rather, I say statements of faith are a description of God, which is not a list of what we believe. It is a description of God.
Now, if you ask me what I believe, this is what I say: God loves us and wants to covenant with us. And I believe the resurrected Jesus is a glorious sign of that covenant. (Slight pause.)
There is one more layer here. One needs to ask the question, ‘What does covenant mean?’ Covenant means God loves us unconditionally.
And what does unconditional love mean? Unconditional love encompasses forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity.
So, I want to suggest covenant—this forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love— in both the Hebrew Scriptures and in the New Testament— are central to Who God is. Therefore, I praise God from Whom all the blessings of covenant— these blessings of forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love— flow. Indeed, praise God. Amen.
04/30/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, NY
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “There is, unquestionably, a difference between Eastern thought and Western thought. Western thought gets into explaining things, delving into detail. Eastern thought tends to look at the an experience as opposed to explaining it. It could also be said Christianity is an Eastern religion which we Westerners try to explain using Western philosophy. Perhaps we would be wise to concentrate on the experience of God’s forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love.”
BENEDICTION: Let us serve the world in the name of Christ. Let the love of Christ find expression in us. And may we love God so much, that we love nothing else too much. May we be so in awe of God, that we are in awe of no one else and nothing else. Amen.
Explaining Scripture
“They said to each other, ‘Were not our hearts burning within us while Jesus was talking to us on the road, explaining the Scripture to us?’” — Luke 24:32.
In my first year as pastor here I was asked this question: “When we recite a creed in the service, I’ve noticed you always use the Nicene Creed. Why don’t you use the Apostles’ Creed?”
“Well,” I explained, “as far as anyone can tell, no Apostle had any hand in or even heard of the Apostles’ Creed. It was written a long, long time after the Apostles were alive and actually a long, long time after the Nicene Creed was composed.” (Slight pause.)
Let me unpack that a little. The earliest trace of anything called the Apostles’ Creed happened nearly 700 years after the Resurrection, sometime around the year 710 of the Common Era. Further, the first written trace of the Apostles’ Creed is found in what we today call France.
Now as to why the Apostles’ Creed spread and became popular, the Emperor Charlemagne had a significant impact on that. Charlemagne ruled the Holy Roman Empire, as it was called, from the year 800 to 814 of the Common Era. Despite the fact that it was only about 100 years old at that point— perhaps Charlemagne didn’t know that— the Emperor insisted the Apostles’ Creed be used throughout the Empire.
Thereby, the Apostles’ Creed became widely used in the West. That’s not a surprise since the Apostles’ Creed is a product of Europe, a product of the West. But it has never been used in liturgical practice in Eastern Orthodox Churches. And that’s not a surprise either since Eastern Orthodox Churches were largely outside of Charlemagne’s influence.
Now, as to why one might use the Nicene Creed rather than the Apostles’ Creed, the answer is simple given the history I just recited. And, to elaborate on the Nicene Creed a little, it was composed by a church council which met in the city of Nicaea in what is modern day Turkey.
This happened in the year 325 of the Common Era. It was the first unified Church Council ever and this creed is used in both the church in the East and the church in the West. Further, the Nicene Creed is the only Creed ever sanctioned by any council of the church. (Slight pause.)
So, why bring up all this about church creeds? Well, toward the end of today’s Gospel reading we hear a very interesting statement. The two travelers who have encountered Jesus return to where the disciples are gathered and hear these words: “Christ has risen! It is true! Jesus has appeared to Simon!” These words from Luke reflect what Paul writes about thirty years before Luke is composed.
And what Paul records is what some call the earliest Creed of the church because these words probably pre-date even Paul’s writings. Paul says Christ was (quote:) “...buried and..., on the third day, Christ was raised in accordance with the Scriptures and... was seen by Cephas— Peter...”— part of an early record in the writings of Paul and exactly what we hear in Luke. (Slight pause.)
We find these words in the work known as Luke: “They said to each other, ‘Were not our hearts burning within us while Jesus was talking to us on the road, explaining the Scripture to us?’” (Slight pause.)
I need to make an obvious statement. We live in the year 2017 of the Common Era. Sometimes that gets in our way when we try to understand stories which were written 2,000 years ago.
You see, when we hear the question, “Are you the only one visiting Jerusalem who does not know the things that have taken place there...?” our brains can play a little bit of a trick on us. One reaction might be ‘did this person not buy the newspaper and read the headlines that morning?’ As I am sure you realize, there were no newspapers.
Further, estimates of the population in Jerusalem run anywhere from a low of 20,000 to a high of more than 1,000,000. The most credible of these estimates run in the range of 100,000.
But this was also the Passover season, so it’s likely many, many pilgrims were in town because of that. So for sake of argument, let’s put the estimated population of Jerusalem this time at about 150,000.
My point is, especially with a population that large, news did not travel with any speed at all in ancient times. So, one might start to wonder why that question about ‘did you not hear what happened’ is even in this story.
That would not have spread. Why ask that question? You see, that someone might have heard this among a population this large in Biblical times just stretches credulity. And, therefore, one might, I certainly do, start to ask, “what is really going on here with this story?” or “What is this story getting at?”
I need follow all that up with yet another statement, but this one is less than obvious. The manuscript from which these words are taken depicts the village of Emmaus as being some seven miles from Jerusalem. Other ancient manuscripts say Emmaus is twenty miles out from Jerusalem.
However, Biblical historians have never been able to find any ancient town with the name Emmaus. Further, there does not even seem to be any hidden meaning it the name. Its likely meaning is “warm spring.” So the name is completely innocuous.
I think all this information again prompts me to ask questions like, “where is this story trying to lead us?” “What is it trying to tell us?”
Well, that’s when I turn to the phrase that says Jesus explained Scripture to these travelers. More specifically, what does it mean that Jesus explained Scripture (quote:) “...beginning with Moses and all the prophets,...”? (Slight pause.)
I need to make one more obvious statement. The only Scripture Jesus knew is what we call the Hebrew Scriptures, the Old Testament.
And for those who first heard or read this story, the words used here— ‘Moses and all the prophets’— would have had a very specific meaning. When the word Moses was used referring to Scripture in ancient times people took it to mean the Torah, the Pentateuch— the Book of Moses. Add the Prophets to that and what do you have? The only Scripture Jesus knew.
And what does the Torah and the Prophets— the Hebrew Scripture— the only Scripture Jesus knew, say? The Hebrew Scripture insists God loves us and God wants to be in covenant with us. (Slight pause.)
Now I suppose you have noticed over time that I often speak about the covenant of God. Why would I concentrate on covenant so much? Well here’s one thing. Scholars tell us there are at least 12 signs of the covenant in the Hebrew Scripture— signs of the covenant with Noah, with Abraham, with Moses, with David, with the Priests.
And again, what does that covenant in Hebrew Scripture say? It says God loves us and wants to be in covenant with us. That is what the Hebrew Scripture— the only Bible Jesus knew— is about. That’s it; that’s all; case closed— covenant. (Slight pause.)
Now, I can hear the skeptical among you say what Jesus explained had to do with the Messiah. And that is not about covenant. My take on this is simple. The resurrected Jesus is yet another a sign of the covenant.
Why do I say the resurrected Jesus is a sign of the covenant? Here’s one reason right from this reading. (Quote:) “Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it and gave it to them.”
When we celebrate Communion still today the words we use insist the meal is a sign of the covenant. (Quote:) “This cup is the new covenant— the new covenant.” (Slight pause.)
All that brings me back to statements of faith, what we commonly called creeds. I maintain statements of faith are not a list of what we believe, although many people take them that way. Rather, I say statements of faith are a description of God, which is not a list of what we believe. It is a description of God.
Now, if you ask me what I believe, this is what I say: God loves us and wants to covenant with us. And I believe the resurrected Jesus is a glorious sign of that covenant. (Slight pause.)
There is one more layer here. One needs to ask the question, ‘What does covenant mean?’ Covenant means God loves us unconditionally.
And what does unconditional love mean? Unconditional love encompasses forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity.
So, I want to suggest covenant—this forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love— in both the Hebrew Scriptures and in the New Testament— are central to Who God is. Therefore, I praise God from Whom all the blessings of covenant— these blessings of forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love— flow. Indeed, praise God. Amen.
04/30/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, NY
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “There is, unquestionably, a difference between Eastern thought and Western thought. Western thought gets into explaining things, delving into detail. Eastern thought tends to look at the an experience as opposed to explaining it. It could also be said Christianity is an Eastern religion which we Westerners try to explain using Western philosophy. Perhaps we would be wise to concentrate on the experience of God’s forgiveness, joy, peace, hope, freedom, equity and love.”
BENEDICTION: Let us serve the world in the name of Christ. Let the love of Christ find expression in us. And may we love God so much, that we love nothing else too much. May we be so in awe of God, that we are in awe of no one else and nothing else. Amen.
Sunday, April 23, 2017
SERMON ~ 04/23/2017 ~ “Abba, God”
04/23/2017 ~ Second Sunday of Easter ~ *Acts 2:14a, 22-32; Psalm 16; 1 Peter 1:3-9; John 20:19-31 ~ Blessing/Dedication of the Quilts.
Abba, God
“Blessed be Abba, God of our Savior, Jesus, the Christ, who with great mercy gave us a new birth: a birth into a living hope which draws its life from the resurrection of Jesus, the Christ, from the dead;...” — 1 Peter 1:3.
On April 13, 1970, the Apollo 13 mission, on its way to the moon, was rocked by an onboard explosion. The command module went dark. Astronaut Jim Lovell radioed mission control: “Houston, we have a problem.”
And so, “Houston, we have a problem” became a cultural touchstone. Books, movies, sportscasters, politicians, plays, novels, use these words as shorthand for saying something has gone terribly awry.
Except... the astronaut Jim Lovell did not say that. Indeed, no astronaut on Apollo 13 said, “Houston, we have a problem.” So, that’s not just one of the all-time great misquotes. It is a cultural myth.
First and to be accurate— astronaut Russ Swigert, not Jim Lovell did say something. But what was actually said was a little more prosaic, less poetic. “Okay, Houston, we’ve had a problem here.”
Now, I’d be the first to say that’s not a big difference. But it is different. As I said— more prosaic. It’s slower. And it’s in a different tense. So where did the idea that Jim Lovell said “Houston, we have a problem” come from, anyway? (Slight pause.)
If you guessed from the movies you would be both right and wrong. Soon after the movie Apollo 13— a movie in which Lovell was played by Tom Hanks, so they wouldn’t let the other astronaut do it because Tom Hanks was playing that part— in which Lovell was played by Tom Hanks and is given that line— soon after the movie Apollo 13 was released, the world became infected with these words, easily one of the most used catchphrases ever.
But it makes sense that the phrase was rewritten for the movies. As its screen writer William Broyles has insisted, you can’t say something has happened. Because if you say something has happened it’s over. It’s done. That may be what was really said. But it’s not dramatic. And this was a suspense movie. Suspense needs to be present, to be continual.
On the other hand, the movie was only partially to blame for this myth. In 1983 National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA, used “Houston, we have a problem” as the title of its weekly radio program about... space history. [1] (Slight pause.)
There are all kinds of cultural myths, things into which the culture buys, that are simply not true. And indeed, the culture imposes all kinds of myths on Christianity.
Here’s an example. The iconic image of the cross widely used by and in the culture has a central vertical beam transected by a horizontal beam about a third of the way down— like that one. (The pastor points to the chancel cross.)
But the actual crosses Romans used to kill people was different. The cross on which Jesus was executed was probably T-shaped— a vertical element with a horizontal beam on top, like a ‘T.’ That allowed executioners to tie the victim to bean then raise the person being murdered to the top.
Here’s another myth along the same lines. Rumor to the contrary, the cross was not a symbol used by early Christians.
The symbol of a cross was extremely rare before the mid-4th Century of the Common Era. And depictions of Jesus on a cross did not occur with regularity until the 6th century. And when these first appeared, the image of Christ was that of a monarch dressed in royal garb levitating off the cross. They tried to make it look like Jesus was not nailed to the cross.
So Christianity is 300 years old before the image of a cross becomes common and 600 years old before the crucifix— a cross with a body— becomes common. It’s at least another century before a partially naked body on the cross, the image often seen today, becomes common. But myths— myths meaning falsehoods in this case— imposed by a cultural eons after the New Testament times insist these images should be paramount when they have no real relation to when things happened and how things were looked at. [2] (Slight pause.)
We find these words in First Peter: “Blessed be Abba, God of our Savior, Jesus, the Christ, who with great mercy gave us a new birth: a birth into a living hope which draws its life from the resurrection of Jesus, the Christ, from the dead;...”
First Peter is one of the so called ‘general epistles,’ not attributed to Paul, not addressed to a particular church. Here it speaks to the condition of churches across lines of time and place.
One commentary says this letter is written for churches alienated from the surrounding society. Put differently, the early church is a counter-cultural church. The early church does not buy into the dominant culture, does not buy into imposed cultural myths. [3]
Now, a more traditional translation for this passage would have said (quote:) “Blessed be the God and Father of Jesus Christ.” But if the churches to which this letter was sent did not buy into the dominant culture, did not acquiesce to imposed cultural myths, they would never have referred to God as Father.
Why? Only those associated with the dominant culture of the era— the Romans— would have referred to God as Father, common in the Roman culture. Further, and as I have often said here, you can search all of Scripture and you will not find God referred to as “Father” in the original languages. It’s not found in the Hebrew Scriptures, not found in the New Testament. To call God Father is simply an imposition of the Roman culture on Christianity.
Jesus does, however, call God Abba, which means “Daddy.” This is and is meant to be a term of intimacy, a relational term.
All that brings me to what I think are the key questions raised by this reading. Who is Abba, God? What does Abba, God have to do with resurrection? (Slight pause.)
Well, having said God is relational, let’s take that a step further. In the Congregational tradition we often use the term covenant. In fact, covenant is meant to have familial, relational understandings, familial, relational meanings. Since God is a God of covenant the claim made in Scripture and by our forebears— God adopts us as God’s own— relational. (Slight pause.)
I tried to unpack all that because I want to illustrate that this epistle is, in its own way, quite counter-cultural. Let’s start with the words Savior and salvation.
At the beginning of this reading the word Savior is applied to Jesus. But we need to realize Savior is not an exclusively Christian term. Savior is applied to God in the Hebrew Scriptures constantly. Hence, the relationship of Jesus and God is here intertwined in an intimate way.
Now, the word salvation has a very specific meaning in the context of Scripture. And this passage says (quote:) “...you are receiving the outcome of your faith— salvation.” In the context of Scripture salvation means freedom.
I believe this passage, therefore, offers a very specific, very direct message. The resurrected Jesus is a sign from God and a sign of God that the promises of God are real.
(Quote:) “Christ, who with great mercy gave us a new birth: a birth into a living hope....” The resurrected Jesus is a sign from God that freedom— the freedom God offers— is real, a sign from God that God not only wants to be but is in intimate relationship with us.
Further, all this is not a transaction, something paid for, something bought. Relationships are not bought or sold, not something bargained for. That a relationship with God can be relegated to a transaction is, I believe, a cultural imposition placed on Christianity.
After all, the culture thinks there is a cost for everything, everything can be bought or sold. But this passage tells us God willingly, freely and graciously wants to be in relationship with us now and forever. In short, this passage is counter-cultural. (Slight pause.)
In a couple of minutes we, as a Congregation, will be doing something very counter-cultural. We will dedicate some quilts. One could argue these quilts are worth quite a bit of money. But that would imply a transaction— something cultural.
But no money will be taken or accepted for these quilts. They will, rather, be given away to those who need them. And doing that is counter cultural. And, like it or not, we Christians are just that: counter cultural.
How do I know we Christians are counter cultural? Well, the last time I looked we believe God— no one else— offers freedom. We believe peace is possible. We believe hope is real. We believe joy abounds. We believe love lasts forever. And we believe God gives all this to us freely. No transaction is involved.
Indeed, the last time I looked that kind of trust— trust in the realities of freedom, peace, hope, joy and love are in short supply in the culture around us. Therefore, by definition, I’d say we Christians are counter cultural, especially because we trust that the freedom, hope, peace, joy, love of God is with us now and forever— no strings attached. Amen.
04/23/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York.
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “Earlier I said the Romans referred to God as Father. So how did that term creep into Christianity? There are a myriad of ways but there is no doubt that this is one way and it has to do with language, linguistics: by 315 of the Common Era Christianity is the official religion of the Empire. And the Latin words Deus Pater— which mean God the Father— sound very much like the Roman god Jupiter— Deus Pater— Jupiter. And, again, that’s bring historians studying language— no theology there at all; it’s about language. In short, about 1,700 years ago the church probably adopted those words and simply used what was common in the culture and in so doing acquiesced to the culture because it’s certainly not a Scriptural term.”
BENEDICTION: Go out in the strength and love God provides. Praise the deeds of God by the way you live, by the way you love. And may the steadfast love of God and the peace of Christ, which surpasses understanding, keep our minds and hearts in the companionship and will of the Holy Spirit, this day and forever more. Amen.
[1] See this article:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/retropolis/wp/2017/04/13/houston-we-have-a-problem-the-amazing-history-of-the-iconic-apollo-13-misquote/?utm_term=.fdfa6c3520e8
[2] See this article:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-the-cross/2017/04/14/dae63c1a-1fa8-11e7-be2a-3a1fb24d4671_story.html
[3] This information is from The Interpreter’s Bible, the electronic edition in the section which covers an introduction to 1 Peter.
Abba, God
“Blessed be Abba, God of our Savior, Jesus, the Christ, who with great mercy gave us a new birth: a birth into a living hope which draws its life from the resurrection of Jesus, the Christ, from the dead;...” — 1 Peter 1:3.
On April 13, 1970, the Apollo 13 mission, on its way to the moon, was rocked by an onboard explosion. The command module went dark. Astronaut Jim Lovell radioed mission control: “Houston, we have a problem.”
And so, “Houston, we have a problem” became a cultural touchstone. Books, movies, sportscasters, politicians, plays, novels, use these words as shorthand for saying something has gone terribly awry.
Except... the astronaut Jim Lovell did not say that. Indeed, no astronaut on Apollo 13 said, “Houston, we have a problem.” So, that’s not just one of the all-time great misquotes. It is a cultural myth.
First and to be accurate— astronaut Russ Swigert, not Jim Lovell did say something. But what was actually said was a little more prosaic, less poetic. “Okay, Houston, we’ve had a problem here.”
Now, I’d be the first to say that’s not a big difference. But it is different. As I said— more prosaic. It’s slower. And it’s in a different tense. So where did the idea that Jim Lovell said “Houston, we have a problem” come from, anyway? (Slight pause.)
If you guessed from the movies you would be both right and wrong. Soon after the movie Apollo 13— a movie in which Lovell was played by Tom Hanks, so they wouldn’t let the other astronaut do it because Tom Hanks was playing that part— in which Lovell was played by Tom Hanks and is given that line— soon after the movie Apollo 13 was released, the world became infected with these words, easily one of the most used catchphrases ever.
But it makes sense that the phrase was rewritten for the movies. As its screen writer William Broyles has insisted, you can’t say something has happened. Because if you say something has happened it’s over. It’s done. That may be what was really said. But it’s not dramatic. And this was a suspense movie. Suspense needs to be present, to be continual.
On the other hand, the movie was only partially to blame for this myth. In 1983 National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA, used “Houston, we have a problem” as the title of its weekly radio program about... space history. [1] (Slight pause.)
There are all kinds of cultural myths, things into which the culture buys, that are simply not true. And indeed, the culture imposes all kinds of myths on Christianity.
Here’s an example. The iconic image of the cross widely used by and in the culture has a central vertical beam transected by a horizontal beam about a third of the way down— like that one. (The pastor points to the chancel cross.)
But the actual crosses Romans used to kill people was different. The cross on which Jesus was executed was probably T-shaped— a vertical element with a horizontal beam on top, like a ‘T.’ That allowed executioners to tie the victim to bean then raise the person being murdered to the top.
Here’s another myth along the same lines. Rumor to the contrary, the cross was not a symbol used by early Christians.
The symbol of a cross was extremely rare before the mid-4th Century of the Common Era. And depictions of Jesus on a cross did not occur with regularity until the 6th century. And when these first appeared, the image of Christ was that of a monarch dressed in royal garb levitating off the cross. They tried to make it look like Jesus was not nailed to the cross.
So Christianity is 300 years old before the image of a cross becomes common and 600 years old before the crucifix— a cross with a body— becomes common. It’s at least another century before a partially naked body on the cross, the image often seen today, becomes common. But myths— myths meaning falsehoods in this case— imposed by a cultural eons after the New Testament times insist these images should be paramount when they have no real relation to when things happened and how things were looked at. [2] (Slight pause.)
We find these words in First Peter: “Blessed be Abba, God of our Savior, Jesus, the Christ, who with great mercy gave us a new birth: a birth into a living hope which draws its life from the resurrection of Jesus, the Christ, from the dead;...”
First Peter is one of the so called ‘general epistles,’ not attributed to Paul, not addressed to a particular church. Here it speaks to the condition of churches across lines of time and place.
One commentary says this letter is written for churches alienated from the surrounding society. Put differently, the early church is a counter-cultural church. The early church does not buy into the dominant culture, does not buy into imposed cultural myths. [3]
Now, a more traditional translation for this passage would have said (quote:) “Blessed be the God and Father of Jesus Christ.” But if the churches to which this letter was sent did not buy into the dominant culture, did not acquiesce to imposed cultural myths, they would never have referred to God as Father.
Why? Only those associated with the dominant culture of the era— the Romans— would have referred to God as Father, common in the Roman culture. Further, and as I have often said here, you can search all of Scripture and you will not find God referred to as “Father” in the original languages. It’s not found in the Hebrew Scriptures, not found in the New Testament. To call God Father is simply an imposition of the Roman culture on Christianity.
Jesus does, however, call God Abba, which means “Daddy.” This is and is meant to be a term of intimacy, a relational term.
All that brings me to what I think are the key questions raised by this reading. Who is Abba, God? What does Abba, God have to do with resurrection? (Slight pause.)
Well, having said God is relational, let’s take that a step further. In the Congregational tradition we often use the term covenant. In fact, covenant is meant to have familial, relational understandings, familial, relational meanings. Since God is a God of covenant the claim made in Scripture and by our forebears— God adopts us as God’s own— relational. (Slight pause.)
I tried to unpack all that because I want to illustrate that this epistle is, in its own way, quite counter-cultural. Let’s start with the words Savior and salvation.
At the beginning of this reading the word Savior is applied to Jesus. But we need to realize Savior is not an exclusively Christian term. Savior is applied to God in the Hebrew Scriptures constantly. Hence, the relationship of Jesus and God is here intertwined in an intimate way.
Now, the word salvation has a very specific meaning in the context of Scripture. And this passage says (quote:) “...you are receiving the outcome of your faith— salvation.” In the context of Scripture salvation means freedom.
I believe this passage, therefore, offers a very specific, very direct message. The resurrected Jesus is a sign from God and a sign of God that the promises of God are real.
(Quote:) “Christ, who with great mercy gave us a new birth: a birth into a living hope....” The resurrected Jesus is a sign from God that freedom— the freedom God offers— is real, a sign from God that God not only wants to be but is in intimate relationship with us.
Further, all this is not a transaction, something paid for, something bought. Relationships are not bought or sold, not something bargained for. That a relationship with God can be relegated to a transaction is, I believe, a cultural imposition placed on Christianity.
After all, the culture thinks there is a cost for everything, everything can be bought or sold. But this passage tells us God willingly, freely and graciously wants to be in relationship with us now and forever. In short, this passage is counter-cultural. (Slight pause.)
In a couple of minutes we, as a Congregation, will be doing something very counter-cultural. We will dedicate some quilts. One could argue these quilts are worth quite a bit of money. But that would imply a transaction— something cultural.
But no money will be taken or accepted for these quilts. They will, rather, be given away to those who need them. And doing that is counter cultural. And, like it or not, we Christians are just that: counter cultural.
How do I know we Christians are counter cultural? Well, the last time I looked we believe God— no one else— offers freedom. We believe peace is possible. We believe hope is real. We believe joy abounds. We believe love lasts forever. And we believe God gives all this to us freely. No transaction is involved.
Indeed, the last time I looked that kind of trust— trust in the realities of freedom, peace, hope, joy and love are in short supply in the culture around us. Therefore, by definition, I’d say we Christians are counter cultural, especially because we trust that the freedom, hope, peace, joy, love of God is with us now and forever— no strings attached. Amen.
04/23/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York.
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “Earlier I said the Romans referred to God as Father. So how did that term creep into Christianity? There are a myriad of ways but there is no doubt that this is one way and it has to do with language, linguistics: by 315 of the Common Era Christianity is the official religion of the Empire. And the Latin words Deus Pater— which mean God the Father— sound very much like the Roman god Jupiter— Deus Pater— Jupiter. And, again, that’s bring historians studying language— no theology there at all; it’s about language. In short, about 1,700 years ago the church probably adopted those words and simply used what was common in the culture and in so doing acquiesced to the culture because it’s certainly not a Scriptural term.”
BENEDICTION: Go out in the strength and love God provides. Praise the deeds of God by the way you live, by the way you love. And may the steadfast love of God and the peace of Christ, which surpasses understanding, keep our minds and hearts in the companionship and will of the Holy Spirit, this day and forever more. Amen.
[1] See this article:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/retropolis/wp/2017/04/13/houston-we-have-a-problem-the-amazing-history-of-the-iconic-apollo-13-misquote/?utm_term=.fdfa6c3520e8
[2] See this article:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-the-cross/2017/04/14/dae63c1a-1fa8-11e7-be2a-3a1fb24d4671_story.html
[3] This information is from The Interpreter’s Bible, the electronic edition in the section which covers an introduction to 1 Peter.
Sunday, April 16, 2017
SERMON ~ 04/16/2017 ~ “Fear and Trembling”
04/16/2017 ~ Resurrection of the Christ ~ Easter Day ~ Also Known as The Feast of the Resurrection ~ *Acts 10:34-43 or Isaiah 65:17-25; Psalm 118:1-2, 14-24; 1 Corinthians 15:19-26 or Acts 10:34-43; John 20:1-18 or Luke 24:1-12; Added Reading: 1 Corinthians 15:3-7 [ILV].
Fear and Trembling
“...Jesus said to them, ‘Do not be afraid; go and tell the disciples to go to Galilee; there they will see me.’” — Matthew 28:10
A vibrant early morning Sun burst over the horizon of the Judean hillsides. In all those places where darkness had lurked before crystals of light splashed brilliant beams. This was a dazzling array, bristling with energy. It seemed to extend itself into new territories, just as a vivacious youngster might intrude, as if probing places it had never even been allowed before.
But all that was happening outside the cave. Inside the depths of this stone fortress, deep in the bowels of it, there was little light.
And it was not just dark. It was also wet, dank. There was a constant drip, drip, drip as pellets of water fell slowly from the roof into puddles on the floor. And so, a long way back from the opening of the cave an eerie essence of night enshrouded two women.
They were both named Mary. But most everyone, all their friends, called one of them Mags. Mags was her nickname because her hometown was Magdala.
Just before the Sun had made its entrance Mary, the faster of the two, was running in front of her friend Mags. She was afraid and decided she needed to hide. It was then, when Mary had made that decision, that this crevice in the side of the hill, this cavern, presented itself. She plunged into the shadows of the opening.
Mags did not, herself, think hiding was the best thing to do right now. But Mary and Mags were life-long friends, best friends. And when your best friend insists on something, you go along.
Mags, the more observant of the two, saw some lamps by the mouth of cave. Mags also had more foresight. She grabbed a single lamp and lit it before plunging toward the depth of night which this hole on the side of the hill presented.
That lamp was proving, however, to be of limited assistance. Given the moisture in the air, its wick had become a little wet. Hence, the flame often flickered.
Also, the cloth which stuck up from the reservoir of oil had gotten to a point where most of it had burned away. It would not be much longer before they needed to move back toward to the entrance of the cave just so they could see.
But for now they sat near one another on the hard floor. And Mary... Mary was weeping. After a time of sitting there next to her friend, just listening to her friend, Mags reached out and touched Mary’s shoulder. When she did that she realized Mary was not just crying. Her whole body was trembling, shaking.
“Mary,” Mags whispered, “Mary, everything will be fine.”
“How can you be so sure?” came the response.
“Listen to what the Rabbi, our teacher, Yehoshua, Jesus, said. ‘Do not be afraid.’”
“You saw Jesus. Please tell me I was not dreaming.”
“Yes,” said Mags. “I saw the Rabbi.” Her head nodded in the affirmative but she wondered if Mary was able to see this action in the dim light.
“Did you see the other one also?” Mary asked.
“The one whose clothes were as radiant as the Sun?” It was a memory Mags did not think she could easily forget. “Yes. I did. I saw that one.”
Mary let out a sob. “Tell me, tell me... do you remember what was said?”
Mags nodded again. “That one also said ‘Do not be afraid;...’”
Mary probed some more. “And what else did you hear?”
Mags was wondering why Mary insisted on hearing all this again but she took a deep breath and continued. “I heard Jesus had been raised and we should go and tell the disciples, our friends.”
“What else did you hear?”
“Well, one of the things I heard,” Mags allowed, “was something we already know. Jesus was crucified, killed by the Romans, an enemy of the Empire.”
“It hurt just to hear those words. I know Jesus died. I saw it. I watched. When it was repeated, hearing those words forced me to relive the execution.”
Slowly Mary responded. “So... Mags... you heard that— you heard that Jesus is dead and you are not afraid?”
“No. I am afraid. I am scared out of my wits.” Mags was again shaking her head up and down and also side to side in the dark. “That is, I was afraid, I was scared out of my wits until... until I saw... Jesus. Then I was fine” (Slight pause.) “But now I’m frightened all over again.”
“Why? Why are you frightened again?”
“How do we explain this to our friends, the Rabbi’s friends?” (Slight pause.)
The wick on the lamp began to sputter, the light falter. Mags spoke up. “I think we need to leave.”
She stood, reached down to Mary and helped her friend to her feet. They hugged. They cried together.
Finally Mary said, “Mags, you’re wonderful. You are a wonderful friend.”
Mags said, “You’re not so bad yourself.”
Slowly they headed toward the entrance of the cave. Slowly the shadows faded away as daylight angled into the opening, bouncing off stones traveling into the cave, seemingly playful, somehow joyous.
Mary and Mags burst out of the crevice on the hill into the full brightness of day, holding each other’s hand. It was no longer early in the morning but the Sun was still vibrant. The light bristled with energy.
Mary looked at her friend and asked, “So what shall we say? What shall we tell the others.”
At first Mags just shrugged her shoulders. (Slight pause.) Then she smiled. “I know. We simply need to be honest. Jesus was with us. We need to say that. Jesus was with us. We need to name that reality.”
Mary said, “Maybe that’s what really frightens me: just saying it.”
Mags shook her head in affirmation again and then was silent for a bit. Finally she spoke. “The Rabbi said, ‘Do not be afraid.’ And I think not being afraid has little to do with this fear. After all, this is really about trust. And I trust Jesus. I trust what Jesus said. ‘Do not be afraid’”
“So that’s what we need to tell the disciples,” she continued. “That’s what we need to tell everyone. We need to trust what God has done. We need to trust that the light... even more light than we can see on this morning... we need to trust that the light of God is with us and will be with us because Jesus is with us.” (Slight pause.)
Mary smiled. “Mags, you’re wonderful. You are a wonderful friend,” she said.
Mags responded, “You’re not so bad yourself,” and reached her hand out to Mary.
“Let’s go find the others. They are probably afraid and they are probably hiding. We need to tell them to trust everything Jesus said. We need to tell them Jesus is with us.” Amen.
04/16/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York.
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “I need to say two things: first, in Aramaic, the language which would have been spoken in Roman Palestine in New Testament times, to be saved meant to be made alive. Second, I am sure the well known American composer Irving Berlin was a nice fellow. He wrote Easter Parade and also a lesser know Easter Song, It’s a Lovely Day, Happy Easter. I want to suggest, however, that to merely say, ‘Happy Easter’ is not a Christian sentiment. So, let me make a suggestion: if someone walks up to you today and says, ‘Happy Easter’ shake their hand and say, ‘Christ is risen.’ ‘Christ is risen’ is the Christian sentiment.”
BENEDICTION: Hear now this blessing and then please join with me in the responsive Easter acclamation found in the bulletin. May the peace of God, which passes all understanding, keep your hearts and minds in the love of Christ, Jesus, and in the knowledge of the Holy Spirit this day and forever. And please join with me in the Easter Acclamation.
ONE: Rejoice, people of God! Christ is risen from the dead! Go in peace to love and serve God. Christ is with you always. Alleluia! Christ is Risen!
MANY: Christ is risen, indeed. Alleluia!
Fear and Trembling
“...Jesus said to them, ‘Do not be afraid; go and tell the disciples to go to Galilee; there they will see me.’” — Matthew 28:10
A vibrant early morning Sun burst over the horizon of the Judean hillsides. In all those places where darkness had lurked before crystals of light splashed brilliant beams. This was a dazzling array, bristling with energy. It seemed to extend itself into new territories, just as a vivacious youngster might intrude, as if probing places it had never even been allowed before.
But all that was happening outside the cave. Inside the depths of this stone fortress, deep in the bowels of it, there was little light.
And it was not just dark. It was also wet, dank. There was a constant drip, drip, drip as pellets of water fell slowly from the roof into puddles on the floor. And so, a long way back from the opening of the cave an eerie essence of night enshrouded two women.
They were both named Mary. But most everyone, all their friends, called one of them Mags. Mags was her nickname because her hometown was Magdala.
Just before the Sun had made its entrance Mary, the faster of the two, was running in front of her friend Mags. She was afraid and decided she needed to hide. It was then, when Mary had made that decision, that this crevice in the side of the hill, this cavern, presented itself. She plunged into the shadows of the opening.
Mags did not, herself, think hiding was the best thing to do right now. But Mary and Mags were life-long friends, best friends. And when your best friend insists on something, you go along.
Mags, the more observant of the two, saw some lamps by the mouth of cave. Mags also had more foresight. She grabbed a single lamp and lit it before plunging toward the depth of night which this hole on the side of the hill presented.
That lamp was proving, however, to be of limited assistance. Given the moisture in the air, its wick had become a little wet. Hence, the flame often flickered.
Also, the cloth which stuck up from the reservoir of oil had gotten to a point where most of it had burned away. It would not be much longer before they needed to move back toward to the entrance of the cave just so they could see.
But for now they sat near one another on the hard floor. And Mary... Mary was weeping. After a time of sitting there next to her friend, just listening to her friend, Mags reached out and touched Mary’s shoulder. When she did that she realized Mary was not just crying. Her whole body was trembling, shaking.
“Mary,” Mags whispered, “Mary, everything will be fine.”
“How can you be so sure?” came the response.
“Listen to what the Rabbi, our teacher, Yehoshua, Jesus, said. ‘Do not be afraid.’”
“You saw Jesus. Please tell me I was not dreaming.”
“Yes,” said Mags. “I saw the Rabbi.” Her head nodded in the affirmative but she wondered if Mary was able to see this action in the dim light.
“Did you see the other one also?” Mary asked.
“The one whose clothes were as radiant as the Sun?” It was a memory Mags did not think she could easily forget. “Yes. I did. I saw that one.”
Mary let out a sob. “Tell me, tell me... do you remember what was said?”
Mags nodded again. “That one also said ‘Do not be afraid;...’”
Mary probed some more. “And what else did you hear?”
Mags was wondering why Mary insisted on hearing all this again but she took a deep breath and continued. “I heard Jesus had been raised and we should go and tell the disciples, our friends.”
“What else did you hear?”
“Well, one of the things I heard,” Mags allowed, “was something we already know. Jesus was crucified, killed by the Romans, an enemy of the Empire.”
“It hurt just to hear those words. I know Jesus died. I saw it. I watched. When it was repeated, hearing those words forced me to relive the execution.”
Slowly Mary responded. “So... Mags... you heard that— you heard that Jesus is dead and you are not afraid?”
“No. I am afraid. I am scared out of my wits.” Mags was again shaking her head up and down and also side to side in the dark. “That is, I was afraid, I was scared out of my wits until... until I saw... Jesus. Then I was fine” (Slight pause.) “But now I’m frightened all over again.”
“Why? Why are you frightened again?”
“How do we explain this to our friends, the Rabbi’s friends?” (Slight pause.)
The wick on the lamp began to sputter, the light falter. Mags spoke up. “I think we need to leave.”
She stood, reached down to Mary and helped her friend to her feet. They hugged. They cried together.
Finally Mary said, “Mags, you’re wonderful. You are a wonderful friend.”
Mags said, “You’re not so bad yourself.”
Slowly they headed toward the entrance of the cave. Slowly the shadows faded away as daylight angled into the opening, bouncing off stones traveling into the cave, seemingly playful, somehow joyous.
Mary and Mags burst out of the crevice on the hill into the full brightness of day, holding each other’s hand. It was no longer early in the morning but the Sun was still vibrant. The light bristled with energy.
Mary looked at her friend and asked, “So what shall we say? What shall we tell the others.”
At first Mags just shrugged her shoulders. (Slight pause.) Then she smiled. “I know. We simply need to be honest. Jesus was with us. We need to say that. Jesus was with us. We need to name that reality.”
Mary said, “Maybe that’s what really frightens me: just saying it.”
Mags shook her head in affirmation again and then was silent for a bit. Finally she spoke. “The Rabbi said, ‘Do not be afraid.’ And I think not being afraid has little to do with this fear. After all, this is really about trust. And I trust Jesus. I trust what Jesus said. ‘Do not be afraid’”
“So that’s what we need to tell the disciples,” she continued. “That’s what we need to tell everyone. We need to trust what God has done. We need to trust that the light... even more light than we can see on this morning... we need to trust that the light of God is with us and will be with us because Jesus is with us.” (Slight pause.)
Mary smiled. “Mags, you’re wonderful. You are a wonderful friend,” she said.
Mags responded, “You’re not so bad yourself,” and reached her hand out to Mary.
“Let’s go find the others. They are probably afraid and they are probably hiding. We need to tell them to trust everything Jesus said. We need to tell them Jesus is with us.” Amen.
04/16/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York.
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “I need to say two things: first, in Aramaic, the language which would have been spoken in Roman Palestine in New Testament times, to be saved meant to be made alive. Second, I am sure the well known American composer Irving Berlin was a nice fellow. He wrote Easter Parade and also a lesser know Easter Song, It’s a Lovely Day, Happy Easter. I want to suggest, however, that to merely say, ‘Happy Easter’ is not a Christian sentiment. So, let me make a suggestion: if someone walks up to you today and says, ‘Happy Easter’ shake their hand and say, ‘Christ is risen.’ ‘Christ is risen’ is the Christian sentiment.”
BENEDICTION: Hear now this blessing and then please join with me in the responsive Easter acclamation found in the bulletin. May the peace of God, which passes all understanding, keep your hearts and minds in the love of Christ, Jesus, and in the knowledge of the Holy Spirit this day and forever. And please join with me in the Easter Acclamation.
ONE: Rejoice, people of God! Christ is risen from the dead! Go in peace to love and serve God. Christ is with you always. Alleluia! Christ is Risen!
MANY: Christ is risen, indeed. Alleluia!
Sunday, April 2, 2017
SERMON ~ 04/02/2017 ~ “The Spirit Bids Us”
04/02/2017 ~ Fifth Sunday in Lent ~ Ezekiel 37:1-14; Psalm 130; Romans 8:6-11; John 11:1-45 ~ Communion Sunday.
The Spirit Bids Us
“‘...I will put my Spirit within you, and you will live, you will return to life and I will settle you back on your own land; then you will know that I, Yahweh, have spoken and I will act, will make all this happen’ says the Sovereign, Yahweh, God.” — Ezekiel 37:14.
In my comments today I want to briefly, I hope, relate some personal history. I know in doing this I run a chance that what I am about to say may directly relate to me only.
I hope that’s not true. I hope you find places where this history, this story— or at least its consequences— might have some personal resonance with you. So please bear with me.
In the late Fall of 1967 I was working for Bloomingdale’s Department Store in computer operations. I was not yet twenty.
As happened to many of us in that era, I got a draft notice. I was to be inducted in the Army on December 5th, it said. That date was, ironically, my mother’s birthday.
I brought the draft letter into the office to show my boss and gave my obligatory two weeks notice. Now without telling me, the company contacted my draft board and had the notice rescinded and delayed for a month so I could train a replacement. Therefore within a week I got a letter saying my induction date was pushed back to January 6th.
And so, on January 6th, 1968 I became a member of the United States Army, spent eight weeks of Basic Training at Fort Jackson, South Carolina, then was shipped off to Cooks School at Fort Lee, Virginia. Why Cooks School?
I’ve always said it’s typical Army logic. I was in computers. Computer— that starts with ‘C.’ Cook— that starts with ‘C.’ In the Army’s way of thinking, if they both start with ‘C’ it must be a match.
Next, I landed in Vietnam— and this is a another date filled with irony— I landed at Tan Son Nhut Air Base, Vietnam, on July 4th, 1968. Yes, I arrived in Vietnam on American Independence Day.
Now, I am not going to tell any war stories. What I want to talk about is post war. Back then, if you returned from Vietnam with less than five months to serve in your hitch, you were eligible to be discharged.
I arrived back in the States on September 8th, 1969— two days over. I was released in San Francisco, took a cab to the airport, grabbed a red eye back home. New York City, here I come. (Slight pause.)
The years 1968 and 1969— and I was either in training or overseas for most of that time— 1968 and 1969 may have been two of the most tumultuous years in American history. Here are a couple of highlights (or is it low lights?) from just 1968 in chronological order. (Slight pause.)
North Korea seized the Navy Vessel, the USS Pueblo. The Tet Offensive was launched. The My Lai Massacre happened. Lyndon B. Johnson announced he would not seek re-election.
The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was assassinated. Riots ensued. Senator Robert Kennedy was assassinated. The country was in shock.
Anti-war protesters clashed with police at the 1968 Democratic National Convention. Many were jailed. Jackie Kennedy married Aristotle Onassis. Richard Nixon won the race for President with 43.4% of the popular vote. (Slight pause.)
And that was just 1968. My point here is not what happened. My point here is I missed it. I missed all that and a good chunk of 1969 too. I was oblivious to it.
Why? I did basic training, where you barely have time to breathe. I moved on to advanced training, where you barely have time to think.
Next I was stationed first in downtown Saigon where there was incoming ordinance all the time and later stationed just off Tan Son Nhut Air Base, at that time the largest airport in the world. Which is to insist during this period you might say I had things on my mind other than current events. (Slight pause.)
Looking at it all in retrospect, I realize when I got back it took me some time to recover, to fit into polite society again, to get grounded, to adjust. I might even suggest part of me never did recover from an experience of trauma and that trauma is connected with three things.
I saw a war first hand. Next, I did not see what was happening here, back in the States, first hand. But most of the people I encountered— that group commonly called polite society— had seen it. Last, to be straightforward about it— and I speak for a lot of Vietnam veterans in saying this— Vietnam veterans, myself included, did not receive a particularly warm welcome from that group commonly called polite society.
That having been said, at first when I did return I went back to work in computer operations. But not long after that I decided I needed to be involved in what I loved. And I loved professional theater. So I took some classes at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts.
To be clear, theater is just like many other job situations. You need contacts, referrals. Slowly but surely, I stared making the links necessary to get work.
As I have said here probably hundreds of times before, I started writing and had more than a modicum of success at that with theatrically related projects. What I have probably never said here before is the exercise of writing was a welcome, psychic release for me. The more I wrote, the more I recovered from my experience. (Slight pause.)
This is what we hear in the Scroll of the Prophet Ezekiel: “‘...I will put my Spirit within you, and you will live, you will return to life and I will settle you back on your own land; then you will know that I, Yahweh, have spoken and will act, and will make all this happen’ says the Sovereign, Yahweh, God.” (Slight pause.)
Ezekiel lived and preached during what may have been the most tumultuous years in the history of the Jewish people. The armies of the Babylon had conquered Judea, besieged and destroyed Jerusalem, took prisoners captive.
And so in this atmosphere of captivity, enslavement, Ezekiel has a vision. The picture seen by the Prophet is one of an abandoned battlefield strewn with bones.
And no wonder. The homeland has been destroyed. Those who survive live in exile. Their world is not just tumultuous. Their world had come to an end.
However, in the vision experienced by the Prophet the outcome of the journey is clear. (Quote:) “...I will put my Spirit within you....” (Slight pause.) I need to explain something. What the Prophet addresses here should not be given the benefit of hindsight, should not be given a Christian reading. This passage is not about resurrection.
While resurrection is a Jewish concept, it is not a part of the Jewish tradition until about two hundred years before the time Christ lives. Ezekiel lives about six hundred years before Christ. Hence, this passage is not about resurrection.
Indeed and as I often say, resurrection is not reanimation nor is it resuscitation. Resurrection is what it says it is: resurrection. In fact, in this passage the bones are reanimated but still do not have life. They simply have animation.
And animation is not enough. Something is missing that gives real life. What is missing? The Spirit of God is missing. So let me state the promise God makes one more time. (Quote:) “...I will put my Spirit within you....” (Slight pause.)
What is this Spirit of God about? (Slight pause.) I want to suggest the Spirit of God is about trust, hope, faith, belief and most of all about a reliance on God. Therefore, the Spirit of God is about God who walks with us, God who walks at our side, God who is our companion no matter... what... happens. (Slight pause.)
I think this is a human truth. We never actually get over trauma. We cope with it. But I also believe that the best coping mechanism known to humanity is trust, especially trust in God. And God constantly invites us to trust.
Once we trust in God— hope, faith and belief follow. Once we see this path of hope, faith and belief we begin to know we can rely on God, know that the Spirit of God walks with us, is at our side, is our companion no matter what happens. (Slight pause.)
Let me say something else very personal. Given my experience, I am not someone who thinks good things will always happen. I am no Pollyanna. I know better than that.
Equally, given my experience, I know life can be hard and sometimes feel brutal. Equally, given my experience I know my life is not of my own doing.
Given my experience, I have come to realize the Spirit of God walks with me, daily. Given my experience, I have come to realize the Spirit of God walks with us, daily. God gives me, God gives us a promise. That promise is one of trust, hope, faithfulness.
Therefore, the Spirit of God bids us to trust God as we go on this journey called life. And yes, there is no promise that all will be rosy, no guarantee that everything is peaches and cream.
But there is a promise. God promises that the Spirit of God will walk with us, be at out side, this day and forever more. Amen.
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York
04/02/2017
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “It has often occurred to me that we all have our own individual God. And for some people God is threatening, frightening, even violent. I think a God who walks at our side is a Spirit of Gentleness. [1]
BENEDICTION: God sent Jesus unto the world that we may believe. God sends us into the world that we may share this good news: in Christ we are not condemned, for Christ came to offer abundant life. And may the peace of God which surpasses all understanding keep our hearts and minds in the knowledge of God, the love of Jesus, the Christ and the companionship of the Holy Spirit, this day and forevermore. Amen.
[1] Spirit of Gentleness (New Century Hymnal # 286) was the closing hymn of this service of worship.
The Spirit Bids Us
“‘...I will put my Spirit within you, and you will live, you will return to life and I will settle you back on your own land; then you will know that I, Yahweh, have spoken and I will act, will make all this happen’ says the Sovereign, Yahweh, God.” — Ezekiel 37:14.
In my comments today I want to briefly, I hope, relate some personal history. I know in doing this I run a chance that what I am about to say may directly relate to me only.
I hope that’s not true. I hope you find places where this history, this story— or at least its consequences— might have some personal resonance with you. So please bear with me.
In the late Fall of 1967 I was working for Bloomingdale’s Department Store in computer operations. I was not yet twenty.
As happened to many of us in that era, I got a draft notice. I was to be inducted in the Army on December 5th, it said. That date was, ironically, my mother’s birthday.
I brought the draft letter into the office to show my boss and gave my obligatory two weeks notice. Now without telling me, the company contacted my draft board and had the notice rescinded and delayed for a month so I could train a replacement. Therefore within a week I got a letter saying my induction date was pushed back to January 6th.
And so, on January 6th, 1968 I became a member of the United States Army, spent eight weeks of Basic Training at Fort Jackson, South Carolina, then was shipped off to Cooks School at Fort Lee, Virginia. Why Cooks School?
I’ve always said it’s typical Army logic. I was in computers. Computer— that starts with ‘C.’ Cook— that starts with ‘C.’ In the Army’s way of thinking, if they both start with ‘C’ it must be a match.
Next, I landed in Vietnam— and this is a another date filled with irony— I landed at Tan Son Nhut Air Base, Vietnam, on July 4th, 1968. Yes, I arrived in Vietnam on American Independence Day.
Now, I am not going to tell any war stories. What I want to talk about is post war. Back then, if you returned from Vietnam with less than five months to serve in your hitch, you were eligible to be discharged.
I arrived back in the States on September 8th, 1969— two days over. I was released in San Francisco, took a cab to the airport, grabbed a red eye back home. New York City, here I come. (Slight pause.)
The years 1968 and 1969— and I was either in training or overseas for most of that time— 1968 and 1969 may have been two of the most tumultuous years in American history. Here are a couple of highlights (or is it low lights?) from just 1968 in chronological order. (Slight pause.)
North Korea seized the Navy Vessel, the USS Pueblo. The Tet Offensive was launched. The My Lai Massacre happened. Lyndon B. Johnson announced he would not seek re-election.
The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was assassinated. Riots ensued. Senator Robert Kennedy was assassinated. The country was in shock.
Anti-war protesters clashed with police at the 1968 Democratic National Convention. Many were jailed. Jackie Kennedy married Aristotle Onassis. Richard Nixon won the race for President with 43.4% of the popular vote. (Slight pause.)
And that was just 1968. My point here is not what happened. My point here is I missed it. I missed all that and a good chunk of 1969 too. I was oblivious to it.
Why? I did basic training, where you barely have time to breathe. I moved on to advanced training, where you barely have time to think.
Next I was stationed first in downtown Saigon where there was incoming ordinance all the time and later stationed just off Tan Son Nhut Air Base, at that time the largest airport in the world. Which is to insist during this period you might say I had things on my mind other than current events. (Slight pause.)
Looking at it all in retrospect, I realize when I got back it took me some time to recover, to fit into polite society again, to get grounded, to adjust. I might even suggest part of me never did recover from an experience of trauma and that trauma is connected with three things.
I saw a war first hand. Next, I did not see what was happening here, back in the States, first hand. But most of the people I encountered— that group commonly called polite society— had seen it. Last, to be straightforward about it— and I speak for a lot of Vietnam veterans in saying this— Vietnam veterans, myself included, did not receive a particularly warm welcome from that group commonly called polite society.
That having been said, at first when I did return I went back to work in computer operations. But not long after that I decided I needed to be involved in what I loved. And I loved professional theater. So I took some classes at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts.
To be clear, theater is just like many other job situations. You need contacts, referrals. Slowly but surely, I stared making the links necessary to get work.
As I have said here probably hundreds of times before, I started writing and had more than a modicum of success at that with theatrically related projects. What I have probably never said here before is the exercise of writing was a welcome, psychic release for me. The more I wrote, the more I recovered from my experience. (Slight pause.)
This is what we hear in the Scroll of the Prophet Ezekiel: “‘...I will put my Spirit within you, and you will live, you will return to life and I will settle you back on your own land; then you will know that I, Yahweh, have spoken and will act, and will make all this happen’ says the Sovereign, Yahweh, God.” (Slight pause.)
Ezekiel lived and preached during what may have been the most tumultuous years in the history of the Jewish people. The armies of the Babylon had conquered Judea, besieged and destroyed Jerusalem, took prisoners captive.
And so in this atmosphere of captivity, enslavement, Ezekiel has a vision. The picture seen by the Prophet is one of an abandoned battlefield strewn with bones.
And no wonder. The homeland has been destroyed. Those who survive live in exile. Their world is not just tumultuous. Their world had come to an end.
However, in the vision experienced by the Prophet the outcome of the journey is clear. (Quote:) “...I will put my Spirit within you....” (Slight pause.) I need to explain something. What the Prophet addresses here should not be given the benefit of hindsight, should not be given a Christian reading. This passage is not about resurrection.
While resurrection is a Jewish concept, it is not a part of the Jewish tradition until about two hundred years before the time Christ lives. Ezekiel lives about six hundred years before Christ. Hence, this passage is not about resurrection.
Indeed and as I often say, resurrection is not reanimation nor is it resuscitation. Resurrection is what it says it is: resurrection. In fact, in this passage the bones are reanimated but still do not have life. They simply have animation.
And animation is not enough. Something is missing that gives real life. What is missing? The Spirit of God is missing. So let me state the promise God makes one more time. (Quote:) “...I will put my Spirit within you....” (Slight pause.)
What is this Spirit of God about? (Slight pause.) I want to suggest the Spirit of God is about trust, hope, faith, belief and most of all about a reliance on God. Therefore, the Spirit of God is about God who walks with us, God who walks at our side, God who is our companion no matter... what... happens. (Slight pause.)
I think this is a human truth. We never actually get over trauma. We cope with it. But I also believe that the best coping mechanism known to humanity is trust, especially trust in God. And God constantly invites us to trust.
Once we trust in God— hope, faith and belief follow. Once we see this path of hope, faith and belief we begin to know we can rely on God, know that the Spirit of God walks with us, is at our side, is our companion no matter what happens. (Slight pause.)
Let me say something else very personal. Given my experience, I am not someone who thinks good things will always happen. I am no Pollyanna. I know better than that.
Equally, given my experience, I know life can be hard and sometimes feel brutal. Equally, given my experience I know my life is not of my own doing.
Given my experience, I have come to realize the Spirit of God walks with me, daily. Given my experience, I have come to realize the Spirit of God walks with us, daily. God gives me, God gives us a promise. That promise is one of trust, hope, faithfulness.
Therefore, the Spirit of God bids us to trust God as we go on this journey called life. And yes, there is no promise that all will be rosy, no guarantee that everything is peaches and cream.
But there is a promise. God promises that the Spirit of God will walk with us, be at out side, this day and forever more. Amen.
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York
04/02/2017
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “It has often occurred to me that we all have our own individual God. And for some people God is threatening, frightening, even violent. I think a God who walks at our side is a Spirit of Gentleness. [1]
BENEDICTION: God sent Jesus unto the world that we may believe. God sends us into the world that we may share this good news: in Christ we are not condemned, for Christ came to offer abundant life. And may the peace of God which surpasses all understanding keep our hearts and minds in the knowledge of God, the love of Jesus, the Christ and the companionship of the Holy Spirit, this day and forevermore. Amen.
[1] Spirit of Gentleness (New Century Hymnal # 286) was the closing hymn of this service of worship.
Sunday, March 26, 2017
SERMON ~ 03/26/2017 ~ “God Sight”
03/26/2017 ~ Fourth Sunday in Lent ~ 1 Samuel 16:1-13; Psalm 23; Ephesians 5:8-14; John 9:1-41 ~ One Great Hour of Sharing All Church Offering Received.
God Sight
“The answer came: ‘The one they call Jesus made mud, spread it on my eyes, and told me to go to Siloam and wash. When I went and washed I was able to see.’” — John 9:11.
The writers George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart were collaborators and titans of the mid-Twentieth Century theater world. They both died in 1961. Kaufman was a writer, director, humorist and drama critic who wrote comedies, political satire, books for musicals and even wrote for the Marx Brothers.
All that made him a good match with Moss Hart— also multi-talented, who also wrote a broad spectrum of material— comedies, political satire and books for musicals. Writing together they won a Pulitzer Prize for You Can’t Take It with You. Another one of their collaborations was the play Merrily We Roll Along.
One conceit of Merrily is that it tells its story backwards. It happens in reverse time, in reverse order. The first scene happens today.
The time sequence of each of the following scenes informs us as to what happened before that and before that and before that. The characters, therefore, move at the start from being older people who look at the world with some distrust, even cynicism, to an the end of the tale where they are younger and envision a future filled with hope and promise.
Therefore, the play often is performed with a second conceit. Since the characters get younger throughout, often young people— twenty-five and under— are cast in the parts. They, of course, start the play acting old and skeptical. By the end of the play they are young, optimistic.
In 1981 the well known composer Stephen Sondheim wrote a musical version of that play. It was Sondheim’s biggest flop, lasting just sixteen performances.
I saw it and I am, hence, one of the few who saw that original production which— by the way— featured a young Jason Alexander, who later came to fame as George on Seinfeld. I was reminded of all this because I recently saw a new documentary about the Sondheim musical.
Back when the Sondheim show was ready to open ABC had planned a program about the making of a musical and intended to use Merrily. Production on the ABC project stopped when Merrily was not successful.
Some of the film shot for that endeavor was recently rediscovered and is part of this new documentary. The documentary looks back at the original Sondheim show using that old, rediscovered film and then covers a more recent reunion of the original cast who gathered to present a concert version of Merrily.
In the old film actors— all under 25— are interviewed about being chosen to be in a Sondheim show early in their career. The optimism of youth is clear in their responses.
In the present the actors are interviewed again these thirty five years later. They reminisce. While cynicism is not a tune we hear, they do talk about where life might have led them and where life has really led them.
Hence the unifying conceit of the documentary, the musical and original play is each looks back in time from the perspective of knowing what has happened. They all look back on life lived and how life played out.
Thereby, questions arise. “If this is where I am now, how did I get here? Who am I, now? Did I become who I wanted to be?” (Slight pause.)
How did I get here? Who am I now? Did I become who I wanted to be?— poignant questions for each of us. Indeed, I was recently having a conversation with a friend, about 15 years younger than I who, reminiscing about who she was when she was twenty-something said, “I wish I knew then what I know now.”
Well, I suppose that is the real conceit of Merrily in all these versions. If we only knew how we got to where we are today, maybe we would have done things, if not differently, perhaps better. (Slight pause.)
This is what we hear in the Gospel According to the School of John: “The answer came: ‘The one they call Jesus made mud, spread it on my eyes, and told me to go to Siloam and wash. When I went and washed I was able to see.’” (Slight pause.)
Few stories in the New Testament are told as well as the healing of the one born blind. Scenes are smoothly connected; characters unfold before our eyes; above all, crisp dialogue, ironic at almost every point, unveils the satire of someone born blind who comes to see and is enabled to see people who prove themselves blind.
The story is a work of art to be admired. In fact, one commentary I read said the story needs only to be told. One should never preach about it. Why? The story makes its own obvious theological claims.
Well, I like a challenge. So I will try to say something about it. (Slight pause.) Toward the end of this tale the one born blind is cast out of the synagogue, cut off from family, religion, heritage, home.
All anchors, all the things commonly perceived of as linchpins of life are gone. I want to suggest that, while the story makes all that happens sound as if it was inevitable evolution, it is not inevitable evolution. Real life is more scattered than it is inevitable. Let me throw out a concept here. We tend to think that knowledge is binary. Either you know something or you don’t. We see knowledge as a fact or a series of facts. But each of those facts, even in a series, is isolated, separate from other facts.
That leads me to ask ‘what is true knowledge?’ Is knowledge a fact or even a set of facts? Or is it something else? (Slight pause.)
I think knowledge is neither a fact nor is it a series of facts. Rather, true knowledge is an ability to connect facts.
True knowledge connects different aspects of life. True knowledge integrates facts. True knowledge is, therefore, complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random, scattered.
True knowledge is challenging. Or rather true knowledge, real knowledge, deep knowledge— by definition— challenges our ususal way of thinking. That usual way of thinking says knowing facts means we are knowledgeable. I am suggesting what really makes us knowledgeable is integrating facts.
Further, knowledge is not simply about winning or losing, certainly something we hear in many quarters. Knowledge is, therefore, a lot like a life lived, a lot like life. It is something we experience over time— complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random, scattered. (Slight pause.)
That brings me back to Merrily We Roll Along. Yes, we all wish we had 20/20 hindsight. Why? 20/20 hindsight sees things perfectly, or as close to perfect as we might imagine perfect to be.
Of course, that is the final conceit of Merrily, the idea that we might look back with perfect 20/20 hindsight. And we think that if we had 20/20 hindsight, we would have the same vision of the world God has. But real life is a lot more complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random, scattered and imperfect than simply having 20/20 hindsight.
Of course, all this brings me back to the textured story of the one born blind from birth. (Slight pause.) I think this story is an invitation to see the world as God sees the world.
However, counter to the way we think the world works, this story is an invitation to not see things as simply facts, an invitation to not see things isolated from everything else. Please understand everyone in the story except the one born blind sees things, sees the world as an immutable set of facts.
And we tend to see the story that way precisely because, like any story, it looks back. It has 20/20 hindsight. But does God see the world in hindsight or does God see the world with foresight? (Slight pause.)
Well, how does God see the world? Does God see the world from the perspective of one person? Does God see the world from the perspective of one nation? Does God see the world as an immutable set of facts? Does God even see the world in hindsight? (Slight pause.)
My bet is our own way of seeing the world is, by definition, limited. And I want to suggest God sees the world more fully than we do. God does not see facts as isolated, immutable. God does not see the world only in hindsight.
God sees all the aspects of life as connected, integrated, complex, textured. God sees the world as emotionally demanding, challenging. Equally and therefore, God does not see the world as being about winning or losing.
The economy of the world, as God sees it is— I think— a world in which equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love reign. The economy of the world, as God sees it is— I think— not a place where distrust and cynicism abound.
This, my friends, is God’s sight, God’s vision, how God sees the world— a world— that world which I’ve just described— in which equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love reign. And if anything, I think that is the lesson we need to hear when the story of the one blind from birth is told.
God’s sight invites us to see the world with the eyes of God, see the world not as an immutable fact or set of facts but as a place in which the integrated textures— the integrated textures of equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love do reign. Additionally, God invites us to see the world with God’s foresight.
Let us, therefore, commit ourselves to seeing the world as God sees the world. Forgive me for suggesting— God sees with the heart, overwhelming love. Amen.
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “I mentioned Jason Alexander of Seinfeld fame was in the Sondheim show. He readily admits he could not have foreseen what happened to him. Equally, in the year 2000 the show finally played on London’s West End, the British equivalent of Broadway. And it won their equivalent of the Tony Award for Best Musical. Life takes strange turns. Life is complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random and scattered, imperfect. None of us foresees fully. But we are called to see how God might see— a place in which equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love do reign.”
BENEDICTION: There is but one message in Scripture: God loves us. Let us endeavor to let God’s love shine forth in our lives. For with God’s love and goodness there is power to redeem, power to revive, power to renew, power to resurrect. So, may the love of God the creator which is real, the Peace of Christ which surpasses all understanding and the companionship of the Holy Spirit which is ever present, keep our hearts and minds in the knowledge, love and care of God this day and forever more. Amen.
God Sight
“The answer came: ‘The one they call Jesus made mud, spread it on my eyes, and told me to go to Siloam and wash. When I went and washed I was able to see.’” — John 9:11.
The writers George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart were collaborators and titans of the mid-Twentieth Century theater world. They both died in 1961. Kaufman was a writer, director, humorist and drama critic who wrote comedies, political satire, books for musicals and even wrote for the Marx Brothers.
All that made him a good match with Moss Hart— also multi-talented, who also wrote a broad spectrum of material— comedies, political satire and books for musicals. Writing together they won a Pulitzer Prize for You Can’t Take It with You. Another one of their collaborations was the play Merrily We Roll Along.
One conceit of Merrily is that it tells its story backwards. It happens in reverse time, in reverse order. The first scene happens today.
The time sequence of each of the following scenes informs us as to what happened before that and before that and before that. The characters, therefore, move at the start from being older people who look at the world with some distrust, even cynicism, to an the end of the tale where they are younger and envision a future filled with hope and promise.
Therefore, the play often is performed with a second conceit. Since the characters get younger throughout, often young people— twenty-five and under— are cast in the parts. They, of course, start the play acting old and skeptical. By the end of the play they are young, optimistic.
In 1981 the well known composer Stephen Sondheim wrote a musical version of that play. It was Sondheim’s biggest flop, lasting just sixteen performances.
I saw it and I am, hence, one of the few who saw that original production which— by the way— featured a young Jason Alexander, who later came to fame as George on Seinfeld. I was reminded of all this because I recently saw a new documentary about the Sondheim musical.
Back when the Sondheim show was ready to open ABC had planned a program about the making of a musical and intended to use Merrily. Production on the ABC project stopped when Merrily was not successful.
Some of the film shot for that endeavor was recently rediscovered and is part of this new documentary. The documentary looks back at the original Sondheim show using that old, rediscovered film and then covers a more recent reunion of the original cast who gathered to present a concert version of Merrily.
In the old film actors— all under 25— are interviewed about being chosen to be in a Sondheim show early in their career. The optimism of youth is clear in their responses.
In the present the actors are interviewed again these thirty five years later. They reminisce. While cynicism is not a tune we hear, they do talk about where life might have led them and where life has really led them.
Hence the unifying conceit of the documentary, the musical and original play is each looks back in time from the perspective of knowing what has happened. They all look back on life lived and how life played out.
Thereby, questions arise. “If this is where I am now, how did I get here? Who am I, now? Did I become who I wanted to be?” (Slight pause.)
How did I get here? Who am I now? Did I become who I wanted to be?— poignant questions for each of us. Indeed, I was recently having a conversation with a friend, about 15 years younger than I who, reminiscing about who she was when she was twenty-something said, “I wish I knew then what I know now.”
Well, I suppose that is the real conceit of Merrily in all these versions. If we only knew how we got to where we are today, maybe we would have done things, if not differently, perhaps better. (Slight pause.)
This is what we hear in the Gospel According to the School of John: “The answer came: ‘The one they call Jesus made mud, spread it on my eyes, and told me to go to Siloam and wash. When I went and washed I was able to see.’” (Slight pause.)
Few stories in the New Testament are told as well as the healing of the one born blind. Scenes are smoothly connected; characters unfold before our eyes; above all, crisp dialogue, ironic at almost every point, unveils the satire of someone born blind who comes to see and is enabled to see people who prove themselves blind.
The story is a work of art to be admired. In fact, one commentary I read said the story needs only to be told. One should never preach about it. Why? The story makes its own obvious theological claims.
Well, I like a challenge. So I will try to say something about it. (Slight pause.) Toward the end of this tale the one born blind is cast out of the synagogue, cut off from family, religion, heritage, home.
All anchors, all the things commonly perceived of as linchpins of life are gone. I want to suggest that, while the story makes all that happens sound as if it was inevitable evolution, it is not inevitable evolution. Real life is more scattered than it is inevitable. Let me throw out a concept here. We tend to think that knowledge is binary. Either you know something or you don’t. We see knowledge as a fact or a series of facts. But each of those facts, even in a series, is isolated, separate from other facts.
That leads me to ask ‘what is true knowledge?’ Is knowledge a fact or even a set of facts? Or is it something else? (Slight pause.)
I think knowledge is neither a fact nor is it a series of facts. Rather, true knowledge is an ability to connect facts.
True knowledge connects different aspects of life. True knowledge integrates facts. True knowledge is, therefore, complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random, scattered.
True knowledge is challenging. Or rather true knowledge, real knowledge, deep knowledge— by definition— challenges our ususal way of thinking. That usual way of thinking says knowing facts means we are knowledgeable. I am suggesting what really makes us knowledgeable is integrating facts.
Further, knowledge is not simply about winning or losing, certainly something we hear in many quarters. Knowledge is, therefore, a lot like a life lived, a lot like life. It is something we experience over time— complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random, scattered. (Slight pause.)
That brings me back to Merrily We Roll Along. Yes, we all wish we had 20/20 hindsight. Why? 20/20 hindsight sees things perfectly, or as close to perfect as we might imagine perfect to be.
Of course, that is the final conceit of Merrily, the idea that we might look back with perfect 20/20 hindsight. And we think that if we had 20/20 hindsight, we would have the same vision of the world God has. But real life is a lot more complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random, scattered and imperfect than simply having 20/20 hindsight.
Of course, all this brings me back to the textured story of the one born blind from birth. (Slight pause.) I think this story is an invitation to see the world as God sees the world.
However, counter to the way we think the world works, this story is an invitation to not see things as simply facts, an invitation to not see things isolated from everything else. Please understand everyone in the story except the one born blind sees things, sees the world as an immutable set of facts.
And we tend to see the story that way precisely because, like any story, it looks back. It has 20/20 hindsight. But does God see the world in hindsight or does God see the world with foresight? (Slight pause.)
Well, how does God see the world? Does God see the world from the perspective of one person? Does God see the world from the perspective of one nation? Does God see the world as an immutable set of facts? Does God even see the world in hindsight? (Slight pause.)
My bet is our own way of seeing the world is, by definition, limited. And I want to suggest God sees the world more fully than we do. God does not see facts as isolated, immutable. God does not see the world only in hindsight.
God sees all the aspects of life as connected, integrated, complex, textured. God sees the world as emotionally demanding, challenging. Equally and therefore, God does not see the world as being about winning or losing.
The economy of the world, as God sees it is— I think— a world in which equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love reign. The economy of the world, as God sees it is— I think— not a place where distrust and cynicism abound.
This, my friends, is God’s sight, God’s vision, how God sees the world— a world— that world which I’ve just described— in which equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love reign. And if anything, I think that is the lesson we need to hear when the story of the one blind from birth is told.
God’s sight invites us to see the world with the eyes of God, see the world not as an immutable fact or set of facts but as a place in which the integrated textures— the integrated textures of equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love do reign. Additionally, God invites us to see the world with God’s foresight.
Let us, therefore, commit ourselves to seeing the world as God sees the world. Forgive me for suggesting— God sees with the heart, overwhelming love. Amen.
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “I mentioned Jason Alexander of Seinfeld fame was in the Sondheim show. He readily admits he could not have foreseen what happened to him. Equally, in the year 2000 the show finally played on London’s West End, the British equivalent of Broadway. And it won their equivalent of the Tony Award for Best Musical. Life takes strange turns. Life is complex, textured, emotionally demanding, random and scattered, imperfect. None of us foresees fully. But we are called to see how God might see— a place in which equity, joy, peace, freedom, justice, hope and love do reign.”
BENEDICTION: There is but one message in Scripture: God loves us. Let us endeavor to let God’s love shine forth in our lives. For with God’s love and goodness there is power to redeem, power to revive, power to renew, power to resurrect. So, may the love of God the creator which is real, the Peace of Christ which surpasses all understanding and the companionship of the Holy Spirit which is ever present, keep our hearts and minds in the knowledge, love and care of God this day and forever more. Amen.
Sunday, March 19, 2017
SERMON ~ 03/19/2017 ~ “Saved by the Life of....”
03/19/2017 ~ Third Sunday in Lent ~ Exodus 17:1-7; Psalm 95; Romans 5:1-11; John 4:5-42 ~ Morning Service with the Whole Church at Chenango Valley Home.
Saved by the Life of....
“So, if we are reconciled to God through the death of Christ while we were still powerless, how much more certain it is that we who have been reconciled will be saved by the life of Christ.” — Romans 5:10.
The first thing I need to say in my comments this morning is “Thank you.” Thank you to the residents of Chenango Valley Home for welcoming us, the members of the United Church of Christ, First Congregational, into your home. We, in the United Church of Christ, First Congregational, believe those of us who happen to be in a similar geographic location should be thought of as members of the same community.
But there is more to it than that, especially when it comes to sharing worship. We believe that when people worship together each person brings with them their own talents, their prayers, their concerns, their joys, their hopes and their sense of the Spirit— the Holy Spirit— who is both working in each of us and is working in all of us and is working in the greater community.
Hence, because of your presence in worship, because of the presence of any one individual, we, the congregation— all of us— we become a new and different creation by that presence, by your presence, here today. Therefore, we, the congregation, all of us, need to strive to affirm God’s works in each of us to move all of us together toward greater fullness, and indeed, toward greater community. The very name of my church— Congregational— indicates we are about community.
Let’s look at those two words for a moment: congregational and community. (Slight pause.) Hebrew— the language used in the Hebrew Scriptures, the so called “Old Testament”— is an interesting language. In Hebrew nearly every word can mean a lot of things.
In fact, in Hebrew— depending on the context— the same word can be translated many different ways. I always say the meaning of Hebrew words can change before our eyes, right in front of us. Now, in the Hebrew Scriptures the underlying word we translate as both congregation and community is qahal.
However, that’s not where the meaning of this underlying Hebrew word— qahal— ends. This word can mean congregation and community but it can also mean assembly, convocation, army, company— company as in a group of people gathered— multitude, cohort, gathering, group, session, crowd, horde. [1]
There is, however, one implication in all these ways of seeing the word— qahal— which is of extreme importance. And that is all these meanings imply the whole— everyone in a group. No one in the group is left out. The implication is we may be a group but we are one. We may be a group— many— but we are one. (Slight pause.)
We hear these words in Romans: “So, if we are reconciled to God through the death of Christ while we were still powerless, how much more certain it is that we who have been reconciled will be saved by the life of Christ.” (Slight pause.)
When this reading from Romans was introduced it was said this Epistle is considered by many scholars to be the crowning achievement of theological witness in the New Testament. It was also said this section touches on one of the bed rock principles of the Protestant movement: justification by faith.
In fact, one commentary I read says the first sentence of this reading makes a basic statement about justification by faith. But then Paul goes on and on and on about it for next four chapters! Equally, the commentary says what Paul says is very complex, hard to read, hard to understand.
And I don’t think I am saying anything you don’t know when I say this— the Apostle Paul is complex, hard to understand. On the other hand it was also just said earlier, stated earlier this is a great achievement of theological witness. If this achievement is so dense that we can’t understand it, what can we do to help us understand it? (Slight pause.)
I started my comments by addressing community. I want to suggest that, at least in part, justification by faith is about community. You see these words tell us we are (quote:) “...reconciled to God.” Further, these words tell us we are (quote:) “...saved by the life of Christ.”
Put differently, we are one with God because of Christ. Put differently yet again, we are one in community with God because of the life Christ. Put differently yet again, we are one people— one with God— because of the life of Christ.
And, please note, what makes us one is the life of Christ, the living Christ. Indeed, our proclamation as Christians is not just that Christ has died. What makes us Christians, our basic proclamation as Christians, is we say— and we shall say this on Easter morning— Christ is risen, Christ lives!
And because of Christ, because Christ lives, we are called to be in community because in community we are reconciled with God. Because Christ lives we are called to be one people because we are reconciled with God. Because Christ lives we, who are all very different, each one of us, are one people, one community, because we are reconciled with God. (Slight pause.)
All of which is to once again say to the residents here at Chenango Valley Home, “Thank you.” Thank you for welcoming us, the members of the United Church of Christ, First Congregational, into your home.
Thank you for bringing with you your talents, your prayers, your concerns, your joys, your hopes and your sense of the Spirit— the Holy Spirit— who is working in you and is working in the members of the United Church of Christ, First Congregational and working in the greater community. And why do I say that? How can I say that?
I can say that because— rumor to the contrary— the basic message Paul has is easy to understand. That message says Christ is risen, Christ lives. And because Christ lives we are reconciled to God. And because we are reconciled to God we are one. We are community. Amen.
03/19/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational
Worship at Chenango Valley Home
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “In the Congregational tradition the building in which members of my church meet for worship is not called a church. It is called a meeting house. The reason the building called a meeting house is simple. That’s where we meet for worship. The building is not called a church because the people, the congregation, the community is the church. You are I and all of us together— people— are the church, the congregation.”
BENEDICTION: Let us rest assured that God is among us and travels with us daily. Let us know that God’s Spirit empowers us to do things in the name of God we did not think possible. Therefore, let us share our love for God with others, confident that God will provide if we are faithful. And may we love God so much, that we love nothing else too much. May we be in awe of no one else and nothing else because we are so in awe of God. Amen.
[1] Strong’s: http://biblehub.com/hebrew/6951.htm
Saved by the Life of....
“So, if we are reconciled to God through the death of Christ while we were still powerless, how much more certain it is that we who have been reconciled will be saved by the life of Christ.” — Romans 5:10.
The first thing I need to say in my comments this morning is “Thank you.” Thank you to the residents of Chenango Valley Home for welcoming us, the members of the United Church of Christ, First Congregational, into your home. We, in the United Church of Christ, First Congregational, believe those of us who happen to be in a similar geographic location should be thought of as members of the same community.
But there is more to it than that, especially when it comes to sharing worship. We believe that when people worship together each person brings with them their own talents, their prayers, their concerns, their joys, their hopes and their sense of the Spirit— the Holy Spirit— who is both working in each of us and is working in all of us and is working in the greater community.
Hence, because of your presence in worship, because of the presence of any one individual, we, the congregation— all of us— we become a new and different creation by that presence, by your presence, here today. Therefore, we, the congregation, all of us, need to strive to affirm God’s works in each of us to move all of us together toward greater fullness, and indeed, toward greater community. The very name of my church— Congregational— indicates we are about community.
Let’s look at those two words for a moment: congregational and community. (Slight pause.) Hebrew— the language used in the Hebrew Scriptures, the so called “Old Testament”— is an interesting language. In Hebrew nearly every word can mean a lot of things.
In fact, in Hebrew— depending on the context— the same word can be translated many different ways. I always say the meaning of Hebrew words can change before our eyes, right in front of us. Now, in the Hebrew Scriptures the underlying word we translate as both congregation and community is qahal.
However, that’s not where the meaning of this underlying Hebrew word— qahal— ends. This word can mean congregation and community but it can also mean assembly, convocation, army, company— company as in a group of people gathered— multitude, cohort, gathering, group, session, crowd, horde. [1]
There is, however, one implication in all these ways of seeing the word— qahal— which is of extreme importance. And that is all these meanings imply the whole— everyone in a group. No one in the group is left out. The implication is we may be a group but we are one. We may be a group— many— but we are one. (Slight pause.)
We hear these words in Romans: “So, if we are reconciled to God through the death of Christ while we were still powerless, how much more certain it is that we who have been reconciled will be saved by the life of Christ.” (Slight pause.)
When this reading from Romans was introduced it was said this Epistle is considered by many scholars to be the crowning achievement of theological witness in the New Testament. It was also said this section touches on one of the bed rock principles of the Protestant movement: justification by faith.
In fact, one commentary I read says the first sentence of this reading makes a basic statement about justification by faith. But then Paul goes on and on and on about it for next four chapters! Equally, the commentary says what Paul says is very complex, hard to read, hard to understand.
And I don’t think I am saying anything you don’t know when I say this— the Apostle Paul is complex, hard to understand. On the other hand it was also just said earlier, stated earlier this is a great achievement of theological witness. If this achievement is so dense that we can’t understand it, what can we do to help us understand it? (Slight pause.)
I started my comments by addressing community. I want to suggest that, at least in part, justification by faith is about community. You see these words tell us we are (quote:) “...reconciled to God.” Further, these words tell us we are (quote:) “...saved by the life of Christ.”
Put differently, we are one with God because of Christ. Put differently yet again, we are one in community with God because of the life Christ. Put differently yet again, we are one people— one with God— because of the life of Christ.
And, please note, what makes us one is the life of Christ, the living Christ. Indeed, our proclamation as Christians is not just that Christ has died. What makes us Christians, our basic proclamation as Christians, is we say— and we shall say this on Easter morning— Christ is risen, Christ lives!
And because of Christ, because Christ lives, we are called to be in community because in community we are reconciled with God. Because Christ lives we are called to be one people because we are reconciled with God. Because Christ lives we, who are all very different, each one of us, are one people, one community, because we are reconciled with God. (Slight pause.)
All of which is to once again say to the residents here at Chenango Valley Home, “Thank you.” Thank you for welcoming us, the members of the United Church of Christ, First Congregational, into your home.
Thank you for bringing with you your talents, your prayers, your concerns, your joys, your hopes and your sense of the Spirit— the Holy Spirit— who is working in you and is working in the members of the United Church of Christ, First Congregational and working in the greater community. And why do I say that? How can I say that?
I can say that because— rumor to the contrary— the basic message Paul has is easy to understand. That message says Christ is risen, Christ lives. And because Christ lives we are reconciled to God. And because we are reconciled to God we are one. We are community. Amen.
03/19/2017
United Church of Christ, First Congregational
Worship at Chenango Valley Home
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is an précis of what was said: “In the Congregational tradition the building in which members of my church meet for worship is not called a church. It is called a meeting house. The reason the building called a meeting house is simple. That’s where we meet for worship. The building is not called a church because the people, the congregation, the community is the church. You are I and all of us together— people— are the church, the congregation.”
BENEDICTION: Let us rest assured that God is among us and travels with us daily. Let us know that God’s Spirit empowers us to do things in the name of God we did not think possible. Therefore, let us share our love for God with others, confident that God will provide if we are faithful. And may we love God so much, that we love nothing else too much. May we be in awe of no one else and nothing else because we are so in awe of God. Amen.
[1] Strong’s: http://biblehub.com/hebrew/6951.htm
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)