Sunday, March 31, 2013

03/28/2013 - HOLY THURSDAY - "IN THE GARDEN" - A PLAY

A READING FROM THE GOSPEL —         Luke 22:39-42, 45-54a [ILV]

[39] Then Jesus left the room and the house and, as was the normal practice of the Rabbi, went to the Mount of Olives; the disciples followed.  [40] When they reached that place, Jesus said to them, “Pray that you may not come into the time of trial, a test.”

[41] Then withdrawing from them about a stone’s throw, Jesus knelt down, and prayed: [42] “Abba, God, if you are willing, remove this cup from me; yet, not my will but Yours be done.”

[45] Then Jesus stood up from praying, came to the disciples and found them sleeping, exhausted with grief.  [46] So Jesus said to them, “Why are you sleeping?  Get up and pray that you may not be subjected to the time of trial.”

[47] While Jesus was still speaking, suddenly a crowd appeared and the one called Judas, one of the twelve, was leading them.  Judas approached Jesus to offer an embrace; [48] but Jesus said, “Judas, are you betraying the Chosen One with a kiss?”

[49] Those who were around Jesus, those who were near Jesus, saw what was going to happen and said, “Rabbi, should we strike with the sword?”  [50] Now the attendant of the High Priest was among those in the crowd and one of them struck this person, cutting off the right ear.

[51] But Jesus said, “Stop!  No more of this!” And, touching the attendant’s ear, healed it.

[52] Then Jesus said to those in the crowd— the chief priests, the officers of the temple guard, the elders— “Have you come out with swords and clubs as if I were a bandit, a thief?  [53] I was with you day after day in the temple and you did not lay hands on me, even though you could have done that at any time you wanted.  But this— this— is your hour— the triumph of the night!”

[54a] And so, they arrested Jesus.  They then brought the Rabbi into the house of the high priest.


In The Garden


NARRATOR:    The Gospel we have come to know as Luke tells us the time came for the Feast of the Unleavened Bread, the feast commonly called Passover.  Jesus and the disciples arrive in Jerusalem to keep the feast there.  One of the twelve, Judas, knows the Rabbi has made enemies among the leaders in Jerusalem.  Therefore, this disciple— some think of him as the practical one since it is he who keeps track of the money the followers of Jesus hold in common— Judas approaches the religious scholars and the Chief Priests, the Temple authorities.  Put another way, Judas goes to the crème de la crème of society in Jerusalem with a plan.  ‘Since Jesus can raise emotions by simply speaking on a street corner,’ says Judas, ‘if you arrest Jesus there will be no fear of an uprising led by Jesus among the people during the feast.’  In Luke it says the one who is to betray Jesus is at the meal but it does not say when that one leaves the company of the others.  So, as this scene unfolds, the Gospel story as we are about to hear it has come to the point where the disciples and Jesus have had the meal and have gone to the garden at the Mount of Olives.  Jesus withdraws to pray while the disciples, overwhelmed with a sense of the events which might be impending, have taken to sleep.  Jesus hears something and speaks.

JESUS:                    What was that?  Who is there.

JUDAS:                    It is I— Judas.

JESUS:                    You did not come with us here after the Seder.

JUDAS:                    No.  But I thought I knew where you would be.  And I was right.

JESUS:                    You were... missed.

JUDAS:                    I had... business... business to which I needed to tend.

JESUS:                    Business— with you is it always business.  You need to think less about business, less about money and more about the Dominion of God, the Realm of God.  The Realm of God draws near, you know.

JUDAS:                    I think you’ve made that clear these last several years.  (Slight pause.)

JESUS:                    So, where were you... really.

JUDAS:                    Rabbi, let me ask you a question: are you willing to give up your strange ideas?

JESUS:                    Strange?

JUDAS:                    Yes, strange.  You just repeated a prime one.  Your have these ideas— you insist on talking about the nearness of the Dominion of God, the Realm of God.  The Romans are too powerful to be overthrown.  So it is perfectly clear the Realm of God is not near.  If that were so, if the Realm of God were at hand, we would be building an army of sufficient force to drive the Romans out of our land.  The Religious Scholars— they understand the Realm of God is not at hand.  They understand how much force it would take to drive out the Romans.  And the Priests— they have control of the Temple.  So, when it comes to worship, when it comes to how we worship, what they want to do is what gets done.  Do you know what they are?  They are practical.  They seem to get along fine with our Jewish King, Herod.

JESUS:                    Herod knows how to play the politics of the Temple and the politics of Rome quite well.

JUDAS:                    Yes, Herod gets along just fine with the Temple Authorities and with all the Romans.  And, of course, you know if any of us gets out of line, then Herod will simply call on that Roman, Pilate, the Prefect, and the troops under his command.  The occupying army of Rome under the command of Pilate can make things very difficult for the people.  If something goes amiss, if there are riots, if there is civil unrest, there would be much bloodshed.  Many people would die.

JESUS:                    The Romans already murder many people each year.  Thousands and thousands are crucified.

JUDAS:                    So I am sure you don’t want any more to die than the Romans deem necessary.  Rabbi, I know you love the people.  I know you do not want any blood shed— not now, not in the near future.  Perhaps in the distant future, when we, the Jewish people, can raise a credible army for ourselves— at that point we can strive to overthrow the yoke of Rome.  But until then, cooperation seems like a wise course, does it not?

JESUS:                    And what makes you think I’m against cooperation.

JUDAS:                    What makes me think you’re against cooperation?  You keep gushing on and on about the nearness of the Realm of God!  You just said it a short time ago!  Did you not?

JESUS:                    Yes.  I think the realm of God is near.  But perhaps I do not think the Realm of God means what you think it means.

JUDAS:                    It means we shall be a free people.

JESUS:                    Does freedom mean bearing arms?  Does freedom mean committing violence?

JUDAS:                    It does for the Romans.

JESUS:                    And what is good enough for the Romans is good enough for us?

NARRATOR:    Peter, who has been asleep in a different part of the garden, comes upon Judas and Jesus.

PETER:                    Judas!  We missed you after the Seder.  Where were you?  Did you go somewhere?  (Slight pause.)

JESUS:                    He had... business... business to which he needed to tend.

NARRATOR:    Peter draws a sword.

PETER:                    I still say this is the only business we need to be in.  We need to be at the throats of the Romans.

JUDAS:                    So, Rabbi, you see?  Even your beloved Simon thinks in the end violence will prevail.

JESUS:                    Simon... Peter... put that away.

NARRATOR:    Jesus turns to Judas and says:

JESUS:                    You were there.  You saw it.  Why do they not understand?  Even at the table earlier they argued among themselves like children.  “Who is the greatest?” was their question.  As if... that mattered.  (Pause.)  Peter... Peter... by brandishing that sword once again you are asking ‘who is the greatest?’  Who can marshal enough force is not what the Realm of God is about.

JUDAS:                    Good luck with that one, Jesus.

JESUS:                    Look, Peter, when I sent you and all the others out without a purse or a bag or sandals, did you lack anything?

PETER:                    No, not a thing.

JESUS:                    So, now you need swords?  Do you want to live in a world where the person who has no sword must sell a cloak in order to buy one?  Or do you want to live in a world where the Realm of God reigns?  Do you want to live in a world where the love of God reigns?

PETER:                    I need a sword to protect me.  I need a sword to protect you.

JESUS:                    Trusting God is not sufficient then?

PETER:                    Rabbi, you know what the prophets say.  You have already told us the prophecies will be fulfilled in you.

JESUS:                    Simon, Simon, listen!  All of you will be sifted like wheat.  All of you will be tested.  But the test will not be a test of power or of greatness.  It will be a test of wisdom and of fortitude.  And so, I have prayed for all of you that your own faith may not fail.

PETER:                    Still Jesus, I am ready to go with you to prison and even to death!

JUDAS:                    You see?  You see what your talk about the Realm of God brings?  I will see you later.  I have to be about my business.

NARRATOR:    Judas leaves their presence.  And, indeed, he will be about his business, the business which has already been transacted with the religious scholars and the Chief Priests, the Temple authorities, the crème de la crème of society in Jerusalem.

JESUS:                    Peter, I do not think you understand.  You may think you would go to prison or even die with me.  But the cock will not crow this day until you have three times denied that you know me.

PETER:                    This cannot possible be.  I will not have it!  I will not deny you.

JESUS:                    Peter, do you not remember what I said earlier?  This cup that is poured out for you is the new covenant in my blood.

PETER:                    I heard you say that.  I am not sure what you meant.

JESUS:                    You will understand.  It will take time but you will understand.

PETER:                    You spoke of the covenant.  Why?

JESUS:                    Our covenant is with God.  The reign of God is at hand.

PETER:                    You spoke of blood.  Does that not require a sword?

JESUS:                    (Slight pause.)  I think... not.  (Slight pause.)  Go, Peter.  Go back with the others for a bit.  Let me be here alone.  I need to pray.  In time you will know what all this means.  But right now it is a time for prayer.  And I need to be alone.  I need to speak with Abba, God.

PETER:                    All right.  I will be just a little bit away.  If you need me, call.

JESUS:                    I shall.  I shall.

NARRATOR:    And Peter went off, back to the others.  Judas had, of course, gone off to fetch the Temple Authorities.  And Jesus prayed.  And so the story unfolded.  Jesus was arrested and crucified by the Romans as a rebel, a rabble rouser.  And there were no riots.  But lives were changed.  And Rome would destroy Jerusalem.  And then Rome, itself, would be destroyed.  But the work of the people of God remained.  The covenant remained.  (LONG PAUSE.)  And we find these words in the Gospel known as Luke (BRIEF PAUSE.): “It was now about noon.  And despite it being mid-day, the light of the sun failed and darkness came over the whole land; and the curtain in the sanctuary of the temple was torn in two.  Then Jesus, crying with a loud voice, said, ‘Abba!  Into your hands I commit my spirit.’”  (LONG PAUSE.)  “Having said this, Jesus breathed for the last time.”

SILENCE IS KEPT

Were You There?        (Soloist)

Were you there when they crucified my Lord?
Were you there when they crucified my Lord?
Sometimes it causes me to tremble, tremble, tremble.
Were you there when they crucified my Lord?

SILENCE IS KEPT

Sunday, March 17, 2013

A New Thing ~ Note: this sermon was offered at the First Congregational Church, United Church of Christ in Corning, New York. The Rev. Marraine Kattell of the Corning Church preached in Norwich ~ 03/17/2013 ~ Fifth Sunday in Lent.




A New Thing ~ Note: this sermon was offered at the First Congregational Church, United Church of Christ in Corning, New York.  The Rev. Marraine Kattell of the Corning Church preached in Norwich ~ 03/17/2013 ~ Fifth Sunday in Lent.

A New Thing

“Look!  I am about to do a new thing! / Now it springs forth! / Can you not see it? / Do you not perceive it? / I am making a road in the desert / I am making a way in the wilderness / I am making rivers in the desert— / setting waters to flow over parched earth.” — Isaiah 43:19.

It is March 17th.  Happy Saint Patrick’s Day!  (Slight pause.)  Rarely on St. Patrick’s Day do I even bother to wear green.

Whereas it is often claimed we are all Irish on Saint Patrick’s Day, my presumption is if my full name— Joseph Francis Connolly, Jr.— does not say I am of Irish descent, nothing will.  I figure for me the wearing of some green on March 17th would be redundant.  (Slight pause.)

A few of you know me from my work in the Susquehanna Association, but most of you do not know me.  Therefore, I’d like to tell you a little something about myself other than the biographical notes you will find in the bulletin.

And yes, if you have not already guessed it, my name— Joseph Francis Connolly, Jr.— by its nature tends to profess another truth.  I am not just of Irish descent, but of Irish Catholic descent.  Further, I grew up in an epicenter of Irish Catholicism— New York City.

But it’s worse than that.  It’s not just that I grew up Irish Catholic and in New York City.  For his entire career my late father was a teacher at a parochial high school.  And not just any parochial high school.

My Dad taught at Regis High School, a well known Jesuit, all scholarship high school on the Upper East Side in Manhattan.   One Jesuit became a particularly close friend of the family.  He was another Irish fellow— the Rev. Vincent O’Keefe.  At one time Vinnie— or as I liked to call him, Uncle Vinnie— was the President of Fordham University, later the second in command of the Jesuits, stationed in Rome and because of that position wound up being a commentator for ABC News on all things concerning the Vatican.

Ah, but it gets even worse than all those connections might imply.  You see, then there’s my mother.  My late Mom was a nun.

Now, I don’t mean to provide any scandal here so, to be clear, she had left the convent far behind and had married my father by the time I came along.  But let’s address the reality of my personal history.  The fact that I stand in this pulpit, any pulpit, given my family history is merely an affirmation that I went into the family business.  (Slight pause.)

It is hard to escape from history.  It is hard to escape from personal history.  It is hard to escape from institutional history.  Escaping from history to a new place, a new thing, can be done.  But it is also well to be aware, in the words of  George Santayana, that (quote): “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”   (Slight pause.)

History— my ancestors arrived on these shores from Ireland shortly before the Civil War, an era when the Irish were stereotyped as uncivilized and their very humanity was questioned.  Advertisements for employment regularly said: “No Irish Need Apply.”

Many regarded the Catholicism of the Irish as an alien, rebellious religion and the Irish culture, itself, as an alien, rebellious culture.  In fact, during the mid and late nineteenth century insurance companies would often refuse to sell Catholics insurance.  Why?  Simply because they were Catholic.   (Slight pause.)

And so, in 1882 the Knights of Columbus was born.  Early on my grandfather, Edward James Connolly, joined the Knights of Columbus.  He joined the 197th Council ever formed.  Today there are 15,000 Councils world-wide.

The initial purpose and the real purpose of the Knights of Columbus was and is to be a (quote) “mutual benefit society,” an insurance company, one from which Catholics could buy life insurance without fear of discrimination.   So, I suppose that specific history does raise the question: are we really all Irish on Saint Patrick’s Day?  And if not, what does that say?  And if we are, what does that say?  (Slight pause.)

We find these words in the Scroll of the Prophet Isaiah: “Look!  I am about to do a new thing! / Now it springs forth! / Can you not see it? / Do you not perceive it? / I am making a road in the desert / I am making a way in the wilderness / I am making rivers in the desert— / setting waters to flow over parched earth.”  (Slight pause.)

On my first day in Seminary the very first class I attended was a survey course in New Testament.  This is the first thing the professor said: “The New Testament is about confrontation.  The New Testament is about confronting in love.  The New Testament is about confronting one another in love.”

“But most importantly, the New Testament is about confronting yourself in love.  Unless you can confront yourself, do not bother confronting anyone else in any way.”  (Slight pause.)  Perhaps that is the real lesson of history: the need to confront who we have been and, therefore, who we are and, therefore, who we might be and, therefore, who we might become.  (Slight pause.)

(As was mentioned earlier), water is a recurring theme in the reading from Isaiah— from the water through which the people passed out bondage, to the cleansing, thirst quenching, life giving presence of the Spirit of God.  So, is water a sign of constancy or is water a symbol of change?  (Slight pause.)

The prophet, first, is clearly reminding the people of what God has done— the Exodus from Egypt, the making of Covenant.  This is an appeal to consistency.  This is a recognition of what has been.  Only having done that does the prophet proclaim the possibility of the new.  (Slight pause.)

It is only when we confront our own history and remind ourselves of our own history that approaching the new even becomes a possibility.  Please note: even after confronting our history ‘the new’ does not become a given.  But it does become a possibility.  (Slight pause.)

Historically we Christians have taken the words of Isaiah to address the thought that in Jesus God is doing something new.  However and therefore, too often we Christians have dismissed the thought that in Jesus God is also doing something old.

The theologian Nicholas Thomas Wright has said that in Jesus we find the “climax of the covenant.”  Jesus, you see, is the Christ, the Messiah.

Hence, in the resurrection of Jesus, in the resurrection of the Christ, we can see and experience both a fulfillment of what has been, what is past, a retelling of our salvation history because of our covenant with God.  But in, by and through our salvation history we can also see and experience the possibility of the new.  We can experience seeing ourselves, experience confronting ourselves right now as a people of the covenant.  (Slight pause.)

There is one thing which I believe to be constantly clear about the covenant God has made with humanity.  I believe that because of the action of God in the resurrection of Jesus tribalism is no longer an acceptable way of life.

We are no longer Greeks or Jews or Irish or Americans or Hispanics or Muslims or Republicans or Democrats or short or tall or thin or chubby any other tribal distinction you care to name.  We are all one, one tribe— God’s tribe— called to be in covenant with God and one another.  That, my friends, is our real history played out into the present and seeing hope for the future.  (Slight pause.)

So, what is this new thing of which Isaiah speaks?  Is it an old thing?  Well, yes, since the proclamation Isaiah makes is about covenant.  Is it a new thing?  Well, yes, since historically we seem to have this proclivity to break into tribes, to not see ourselves as one, in covenant with God, the new is a given.  (Slight pause.)

Perhaps the issues we must face and probably need to face on a daily basis can be summed up in a series of questions.  Who have we been as individuals and as a group?  Can we learn from that?

Based on that, can we just consider the possibility that God honors the old and is always doing something new?  If we can consider it, what will we have to do to work with God, to walk in the paths offered by God— God who clearly sees humanity as one people.  Amen.

03/17/2013
First Congregational Church, United Church of Christ, Corning, New York.

ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Congregational Response and Benediction.  This is an précis of what was said: “Church Historian and Theologian Karen Armstrong says this (quote): ‘If your understanding of the divine has made you kinder, more empathetic and impelled you to express sympathy in concrete acts of loving-kindness, this is good theology.  But if your notion of God made you unkind, belligerent, cruel, self-righteous or if it led you to kill in the name of God, it is bad theology.’”

BENEDICTION: Hear now this blessing, commonly known as the Irish Blessing: May the road rise up to meet us.  May the wind be always at our back.  May we have full moon on a dark night.  May the sun shine warm upon our faces.  May the rain fall soft upon our fields.  And until we meet again, may the hand of God hold us and the wing of God offer us shelter, and the peace of God be with us, always.  Amen.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regis_High_School_%28New_York_City%29

[2] http://www.jesuit.org/blog/index.php/2012/07/fr-vincent-okeefe-sj-remembered/

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Santayana - George Santayana (1863 – 1952).

[4] http://www.victoriana.com/Irish/IrishPoliticalCartoons.htm

[5]  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knights_of_Columbus

Sunday, March 10, 2013

SERMON ~ 03/10/2013 ~ God of Trinity and Mercy

03/10/2013 ~ Fourth Sunday in Lent ~ Joshua 5:9-12; Psalm 32; 2 Corinthians 5:16-21; Luke 15:1-3, 11b-32.

God of Trinity and Mercy

“All of this is from God, who reconciled us to self through Christ and made us ministers of that reconciliation.  This means that, through Christ, the world was fully reconciled to God, who did not hold our transgressions against us, but instead entrusted us with this message of reconciliation.” — 2 Corinthians 18-19.

If you are my friend on Facebook— and I know some of you are friends on Facebook— you realize I do not post a lot or comment a lot.  Many weeks the only post I have is my sermon.

In part, that’s because of the office I hold.  You see, when one holds the office known as pastor, one does have to be careful about how one behaves in public.  If you’re on Facebook whatever you post or comment is in public.

There is no such thing as private on Facebook.  Do nothing on Facebook you would not do in the middle of West Park, right outside the church building.  I am often surprised at how many people don’t get that.

Now, part of the problem with Facebook for pastors is things can be taken the wrong way when seen only in print.  Or as I like to say, “Where is my irony font when I need it?”

In person you can say things in a tone that drips with irony.  When people hear that, they know what is being said is a joke.  An ironic tone does not translate into print.      Now, that some people who hold a specific job might need to be careful in public is actually a fairly common occurrence.  One example— when smoking was more popular, Major League Baseball players, even ones who were in tobacco advertisements, would not be seen smoking in the dugout.  It looked bad.  But between innings a lot of players would sneak back to the clubhouse and there they would puff on a cigarette, unseen.  See— there’s that public presence and then there’s what you do in private.  Sometimes they’re different, aren’t they?

Coming back to the office of pastor, let me tell a story about a misdeed committed by a pastor friend who served a church in New York City.  She committed this misdeed despite being a pastor.  And she would be the first to tell you (if I had not already said it) that because one holds the office of pastor, one does have to be careful about how one behaves in public.

To be clear, she herself, did tell this tale about her breech of behavior, so I have no hesitation in using it.  (Slight pause.)  My pastor friend had just had some foot surgery.  So, with her foot in a cast, she hobbled on to a subway train and felt very lucky to find a seat right next to the door.

Getting that seat seemed like a fortunate coincidence, since the seat she took was the last one available in that subway car.  She found herself next to a twenty-something, well dressed businessman whose head was buried in a book.

At the very next stop the train got quite crowded.  No seats were left which meant people had to stand and hang onto the rails above the seats.  A woman who was clearly pregnant got on with that crowd, passed by my friend, hung on to the rail and stood over that well dressed man who was reading.

With my friend’s foot in a cast, she felt it was unwise for her to get up and give this woman a seat.  Thinking the fellow next to her was simply so engrossed in the book he was oblivious to what was going on around him and that it might be polite for him to offer the woman who was pregnant a seat, my pastor friend nudged this fellow.  He looked up.  My friend pointed to the woman.

He simply looked back down to the book again without saying a word.  Two stops later as the train pulled into a station, the man stood and the pregnant woman immediately sat down, a grateful look on her face.

The fellow had not decided to become suddenly chivalrous.  The train had come to his stop and he was about to get off.  Since my friend was sitting next to the door and since she did have a cast on the foot which was next to that door and since that man was obviously about to go out through that door, she— a pastor— somehow decided it would be all right if she— a pastor— perhaps accidently, perhaps on purpose, held her foot out, encased as it was in a cast, just enough to trip that fellow as he got off the train.

The door opened.  Out he went, tripping on her cast as he moved forward.  He landed face first on the platform.

The doors closed.  The train took off.  She never saw him again.  She did, however, exchange contact information with the woman who had taken that seat next to her.

The woman became a parishioner.  My friend Baptized her newborn child.  And that was certainly a new and innovative and different way of doing evangelize. [1]  (Slight pause.)

Confession, of course, can be cleansing, and in that sense good for the soul.  So, by way of confession, my pastor friend did use that story in a sermon, which gives me carte blanche to repeat it.  (Slight pause.)

And these words are from Second Corinthians: “All of this is from God, who reconciled us to self through Christ and made us ministers of that reconciliation.  This means that, through Christ, the world was fully reconciled to God, who did not hold our transgressions against us, but instead entrusted us with this message of reconciliation.”  (Slight pause.)

I’ve mentioned this before: I had another pastor friend who had a ‘T’ shirt made up for himself.  The shirt read: “Dear God, when I die and go to heaven, please let me not be standing in line next to Mother Teresa.”

The point is we are all good in some way but we are all also flawed.  No one is perfect.  Now, in this passage Paul tackles and answers some very central questions.  These include: “What is the meaning of good?” and “Who is Jesus?”

Second one first— as to “Who is Jesus?” in the Epistles Paul often and in many ways asks that classic Christian question: “Who is Jesus?”  The Gospels also ask the question when Jesus says, “Who do you say that I am?”  What we moderns do not understand is the way in which Paul and the early Christians heard that question, “Who do you say that I am?”

We hear the question as being about our own perception of Jesus.  But for those who first heard the question it was not about their perception.  They knew who Jesus was.

Many had met Jesus or had met someone who had met Jesus.  They knew who Jesus was from first or second hand testimony.  So, they heard this “Who is Jesus?” question as being about how God and Jesus were related, how they related, about how God and Jesus interacted.  The question wasn’t about us.

Paul gives us that answer about that relationship and that interaction (quote): “...through Christ, the world was fully reconciled to God,...”  The language the church has historically used to express that relationship and that interaction is to say Jesus is the Second Person of the Trinity.  God is Trinity.

Now I think the more important point Paul makes is the message God gives us concerning that relationship called Trinity.  The message is about us.  We are reconciled to God.  (Slight pause.)

Now, I know what some people think.  Some people think life is a buddy movie.  So their reaction to being reconciled to God will be, “Well, I am reconciled to God because it’s all about God and me— we are tight.  We are buddies.”  (Slight pause.)

Well, how much of a buddy are you, really, if let’s say you are a pastor but you go around tripping people on the subway?  Yes, the action my friend took may have been— let’s say ‘in a good cause.’  But it was still just a tad over the top, was it not?  (Slight pause.)

So, reconciliation is not about our wrongdoing or even our right doing.  We all do some things which are at least inappropriate, if not downright wrong.  We all do things which are wonderful.

Reconciliation is about empowerment— our empowerment.  Reconciliation is about the covenant with God and the empowerment God wants us to have.  All of which is to say, reconciliation with God is not a result, not a goal, not an end thing.

Reconciliation with God is a journey.  Reconciliation with God is about our journey with God.  Reconciliation with God is about our journey through life.  Or, as our denomination likes to put it, reconciliation is about the idea that God is still speaking with us.  Reconciliation is about the idea that God is still speaking through us.  Amen.

03/10/2013
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York

ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Congregational Response and Benediction.  This is an précis of what was said: “Church Historian and Theologian Karen Armstrong says this (quote): ‘If your understanding of the divine has made you kinder, more empathetic and impelled you to express sympathy in concrete acts of loving-kindness, this is good theology.  But if your notion of God made you unkind, belligerent, cruel, self-righteous or if it led you to kill in the name of God, it is bad theology.’”

BENEDICTION: Let us seek to love as we have been loved by God, welcoming our brothers and sisters.  Let us rejoice in God’s goodness and steadfast love.  Let us follow where God leads.  Let us go on our way with Christ as our companion.  And may the steadfast love of God and the peace of Christ, which surpasses understanding, keep our minds and hearts in the companionship and will of the Holy Spirit, this day and forever more.  Amen.

[1] It should probably be noted that there was much laughter among members of the congregation as the pastor told this story.

Sunday, February 24, 2013

SERMON ~ 02/24/2013 ~ Second Sunday in Lent ~ God of the Covenant ~ NOTE: Both the Reading from Genesis and the Sermon Are Below.

02/24/2013 ~ Second Sunday in Lent ~ Genesis 15:1-12, 17-18; Psalm 27; Philippians 3:17-4:1; Luke 13:31-35 or Luke 9:28-36, (37-43a).

THE READING


Genesis 15:1b-12, 17-18 [ILV] ~ INTRODUCTION: The rituals explored in this passage are rituals of covenant, the great promise of God to humanity.  Abram and Sarah are the vehicles through which the promises God makes are made to humanity.  Hear now this reading as it is found in that portion of the Torah we have come to know as Genesis.

...the word of Yahweh came to Abram in a vision:

“Fear not, Abram!

I am your shield;

I will make your reward very great.”

[2] Abram said, “My Sovereign, my God, what good are these blessings to me, so long as Sari and I continue childless?  My only heir is a foreigner, Eliezer of Damascus, who lives in my household.  [3] Because you have given me no offspring,” Abram continued, “an attendant born in my house will be my heir.”

[4] Then the word of Yahweh, God, came to Abram.  God said, “This one shall not be your heir.  No one but your very own flesh and blood shall be your heir.”  [5] Then God took Abram outside and said, “Look up at the sky and count the stars, if you can!  As many as that— so shall your descendants be.”  [6] And Abram believed Yahweh; and God reckoned it to Abram as righteousness.

[7]Yahweh then said to Abram, “I am God who brought you from Ur of the Chaldeans, to give you this land as a possession.”

[8] Abram asked, “Sovereign God, how am I to know I shall possess it?”

[9] God answered, “Bring me a heifer, a goat and a ram, each three years old and a turtledove and a young pigeon.”  [10] Abram brought all these, cut them in half and placed each half opposite the other.  But Abram did not cut the birds in two.  [11] Then birds of prey flew down on the carcasses but Abram drove them away.

[12] Now, as the sun was about to set, a deep trance fell upon Abram.  And a deep and terrifying darkness enveloped him.

[17] When the sun had set and it was dark, a smoking barrier, a fire pot, and a flaming torch appeared.  These passed between the halves of the sacrifices.  [18] On that day Yahweh, God, made a covenant with Abram, saying, “To your descendants I give this land, from the river of Egypt to the great river, the river Euphrates,....”



THE SERMON

God of the Covenant

“On that day Yahweh, God, made a covenant with Abram,....” — Genesis 15:18.

Abram knew it was a dream.  He was absolutely sure of it.  Yet, he could not seem to wake up.  His feet felt like they were suspended above the ground, floating, and he could not touch it.  Something, he knew not what, was holding him in the air.

And then there were stars.  He was surrounded by stars.  They swirled around at a dizzying speed and lit the landscape below, that untouchable ground.  He could see the moon more clearly than he ever imagined it could be seen.  He reached out toward it with a hand and it skittered away, just out of reach.

And then there were torches.  He was being carried along, floating through a pathway with torches on each side.  Sparks sprayed out from each of them.  He wondered if he would be burned by the cinders, but none seemed to come anywhere near the center of the path where he floated.

He could smell something.  Was something burning?  No.  It was not that kind of smell.  It did smell odd, though.  He felt something.  It felt like... hair.  Was it Sari?  Was it his wife?

He reached out to try to touch the hair.  Yes.  It was there.  It was real.  Suddenly he was wide awake.  A fog lifted from his eyes.  He realized he was lying on the ground next to Jamal, his camel.

He also realized the odd smell was nothing more than hair.  It was Jamal, his camel.  He also realized the hair was Jamal, his camel.  The camel, his transportation for lo these last several years, was sitting on the ground, feet tucked in and he, Abram, was stretched out on the ground next to it.  (Slight pause.)  He spit, trying to get rid of a bad taste.  Jamal snorted and then, as camels are wont to do, Jamal spit also.  (Slight pause.)

Abram stood.  The sun had just barely pushed its way over the Eastern horizon, so morning had, indeed, come.  He reflected on what was still vivid about the dream while wondering what had happened to the night.  Where had it gone?  Why was there so much he did not remember?  Why was there so much he did remember?

“Well, Jamal, where are we, anyway?” he asked the dromedary as he stood in front of it, staring into its eyes.  “Where do you think we are?  Where were we last night?  Did we spend the whole night together?  Did we spend the whole night right here?  Do you remember what happened?  I think I might remember.  But I’m not sure I can quite explain it.”

Jamal said nothing, made no noise.  And, yes, Abram knew Jamal was not going to be forthcoming about what had happened, whatever had transpired sometime in the middle of the night.

Abram also realized that what might be the most important fact to consider was he had spent the night in the desert and had not made it back to the camp where his family was.  He knew his wife, Sari, would not be pleased.

Feeling, perhaps, old or at least a little worn, Abram climbed on the back of Jamal and touched the animal on its neck.  The camel stood.

Tired, he leaned back and did not pay much attention to the trip, did not pay attention to where Jamal was going, confident the beast knew the way back to the camp.  Toward mid-day Jamal started to make deep, guttural sounds.  That’s when Abram knew they were getting close to home and slid off the animal, onto the ground.

He could hear the sounds of children.  He could hear laughter.  A baby was crying also.  Abram came over a crest and could see Sari, tending a pot on a fire.  He ran forward shouting, “Sari!  Sari!”  She ignored him.

He ran up and stood in front of her.  “Sari!  I’m here.  I’m home!”

“Where were you?  Were you partying again?  You didn’t come home all night!  I was worried sick.”

“I’m here now.”

“I have just about had it, you know,” was her reply.  “You leave.  You don’t tell me you are going.  You don’t tell me where you are going.  And I don’t like your friends.  They drink too much wine.  It’s not good.”

Defensively Abram said, “No.  It was not them.  I was not with them.  I have not seen them in days, in weeks.  They are just fair weather friends and I know that.”

“So who were you with?” she sneered.  (Pause.)  “No!  It was not that one again, was it?”  (Pause.)

Abram looked down at the ground.  “You know, I really wish you would not call Yahweh, ‘that one.’”

“And what else should I call that one, this God you talk about?  Have I every seen ‘that one?’”

Abram winced at the question.  “No.  But you have heard Yahweh,” he said.

“No.  You hear Yahweh.  I do not.  I hear birds.  I hear neighbors.  I hear children.  I hear the workers in our camp.  I hear the wind.  I hear the pots bang when they are lifted on and off the fire.  I sometimes even hear laughter.  But you!  You!  You hear voices.  You hear this Yahweh.”

Having said the name Yahweh, she spit.  It landed on a hot rock near the fire.  It sizzled.  (Slight pause.)  “What,” she asked, “do you have to say for yourself?”

“Can I tell you what happened last night?”

He could feel her dark eyes looking right through him.  “Do you think it will help?”

“No,” he answered.  “But I need to say it.”  (Pause.)

“So...?”

“Well, you are right.  It was Yahweh.”  (Slight pause.)

“And...?”

“And God said our reward would be great.”  (Slight pause.)

“Right.  Look, Abram, I love you.  I went with you.  I left the comforts of our great city, Ur.  I left family and friends.  I trekked with you across the plains.  We became nomads together.  Much to my surprise we have done well.  But we remain childless.”

“Yes,” said Abram, “but Yahweh made a promise.  My ‘own flesh and blood shall be’ my heir.  And God had me look at the stars and said ‘...count the stars, if you can!  As many as that— so shall your descendants be.’”

“And then... and then... Yahweh made a covenant with me.  There was a sacrifice— a heifer, a goat, a ram, a turtledove, a young pigeon.  I simply prepared it.  Yahweh, God, eternal— God alone— God ratified the covenant with flame.  If birds of prey have not yet devoured the carcasses, I can take you to see the remains.  I can take you to where the making of covenant happened right now.”  (Slight pause.)

Sari laughed.  She went on laughing for some time.  (Slight pause.)  When she finished laughing, she glowered at him.  “And you believed.”

Abram was silent and once more looked at the ground.  (Slight pause.)  “No.  It is more than belief.  I trusted.  I trust God.  After all, a covenant is about trust.  It’s about who you trust.  You said it yourself.  You said you went with me, left the comforts of our city, left family and friends, trekked with me across the plains.  We became nomads together.”

Abram continued, “That all may have been, as you said, because of love.  But it goes beyond love to the place called trust.  Perhaps covenant is where love and trust become intertwined, inseparable, eternal.  Perhaps that is what really makes a covenant: trust and love wrapped in one.  These are eternal.”  (Pause.)

Sari was silent and looked at the ground.  (Slight pause.)  “Well, yes.  Trust and growth and peace and respect and longing and joy and wisdom and freedom and hope and knowledge and understanding and love— all these are eternal.  All these make covenant.”

“All these are eternal.  All these make covenant,” repeated Abram.

“And you trust Yahweh, God,” said Sari.

“Yes,” said Abram.  “I trust Yahweh, God.”  (Slight pause.)

“Well,” said Sari, holding out a hand, “let’s get out of the sun.”

And hand in hand they walked together past Jamal, who was resting under a tree, snorting and spitting.  Abram and Sari waked together in covenant and in trust and in growth and in peace and in respect and with longing and in joy and in wisdom and in freedom and in hope and in knowledge and in understanding... and in love.  They walked toward their tent, hand in hand, to get out of the noonday sun.  Amen.

02/24/2013
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York

ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Congregational Response and Benediction.  This is an précis of what was said: “Theologian Walter Brueggemann has said this: ‘Covenant (and, therefore, true spirituality), consists on learning the skills and sensitivities that include both the courage to assert self and the grace to abandon self to another.’ In short, covenant is not possible unless you recognize the needs of others.”

BENEDICTION: “Let our hearts take courage.  Our God meets us where our needs rest.  God is our shelter and shield.  God’s blessings outnumber the stars.  Let us go on our way with Christ as our companion.  And may the peace of Christ, which surpasses understanding, keep our minds and hearts in the companionship and will of the Holy Spirit, this day and forever more.  Amen.”

Sunday, February 17, 2013

02/17/2013 ~ First Sunday in Lent ~ Deuteronomy 26:1-11; Psalm 91:1-2, 9-16; Romans 10:8b-13; Luke 4:1-13.

Distinctions

“For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek— all have the same Creator, rich in mercy towards those who call.” — Romans 10:12a.

If you hang around me long enough you will hear me say this— something I say all the time at Bible Study, occasionally from the pulpit and I once even said it at a Rotary meeting.  “Church has a dirty little secret.  Churches are, largely, sociologically gathered institutions, not theologically gathered institutions.”

A short way of saying this would be: like people worship with like people.  And, as I also often say, the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. rephrased the phenomena of like people worshiping with like people better than anyone else.  King said: “The worship hour on a Sunday morning is still the most segregated hour in America.”  I think it’s unlikely churches which are exclusively African American in their make up would be a part of the landscape unless sociology was a part of the picture.

All that is well and good, but what is the point of saying churches are sociologically gathered institutions?  And why do I say it with some regularity?  And what does making a statement which says churches are sociologically gathered say about the theology of church?  (Pause.)

Actually, the point of saying churches are sociologically gathered is a theological stand in one very real and crucial sense.  The point of saying it is to name it.  If you cannot name it, you will never know it’s there.  Hence, naming it is very good theology, since any good theology deals with reality.  And this sociological fact is a reality.

Indeed, the reality of this sociological fact can get in the way of a relationship with God.  But if we don’t know the sociology is there, if we cannot name it, see it, we can’t even begin to cope with the thought that this might be harmful in the context of the local community of faith.  (Pause.)

Now that having been said, let me presume you did you notice the Roman Church was in the news this week.  For the first time in 598 years a sitting Pope will abdicate.  I took a poll among the Pastors who were at the Ash Wednesday ecumenical service.  None of us wanted the job.  (Slight pause.)

I take that back.  The Rev. Ms. Nancy Hale did want to volunteer but also thought that possibility presented other and obvious complications.  (Slight pause.)

In fact, I recently said to a friend that today, as it embarks on the election of a new Pope, the Roman Church may be at the same kind of crossroads it was at in the year 1516.  1516 is, of course, the year before Martin Luther tacked 95 Thesis to the door of the Wittenberg Cathedral.  In theory, this act was the beginning of the Protestant Revolution.  In reality, the Protestant Revolution started the day after Pentecost, but that’s a whole different sermon.  I won’t go there.

So, going along with the idea that Protestant Revolution did start in 1517, there is something Americans don’t understand about the Protestant Revolution.  As one of my seminary professors said: “At least nominally, America is a Protestant country.  So we do not understand that the Protestants lost the Protestant Revolution.”

To come to the conclusion that Protestants lost the Protestant Revolution, all you have to do is look at a map of Europe 50 years after Luther tacked those 95 Thesis to the door of that cathedral.  What do you see?  You see the Roman Church held sway over more land, had more people who maintained allegiance to Rome and those lands and those people possessed much greater wealth than the Protestant areas.  They won.  But in part because of the Reformation, a whole lot of different churches now dot the landscape.

So, occasionally, I will field a question which asks ‘why are there so many churches?’  Often my response comes back to the premise I initially stated this morning: like people worship with like people.  The bottom line is we break out into tribes.

However, another but related answer as to why there are so many churches should not be that hard to figure out just based on the Biblical text.  Go to the New Testament. What do you find?  There is no unity of opinion and there certainly is nothing like “one church.”  That never existed.  That is a myth.

Let me illustrate this premise.  These are the opening words of the Gospel we have come to know as Luke.  (Quote:) “Many others have undertaken to compile a narrative, an orderly account of the events that have been fulfilled among us, exactly as those happenings were handed on to us by those who were original eyewitnesses and ministers of the Word.  I too, after investigating everything carefully from the beginning, decided to set down in writing an orderly account,... so that you may know the truth concerning the things about which you have been instructed.” [1]

Well, if we translate that into modern language, the modern vernacular, here is what it might sound like.  “Hey!  Listen!!  A couple of other dudes— too many if you ask me— have written accounts of the life of Jesus.  They got it all wrong.”

“So now, I’m going to write my version which is, of course, the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.  And boy, not only is my version of the story right, but are those other guys who wrote different versions of this stupid, or what?!”  (Slight pause.)  Can you say: “like people worship with like people?”  (Slight pause.)  Can you say: “differences.”  (Slight pause.)

And we find these words in the work known as Romans: “For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek— all have the same Creator, rich in mercy towards those who call.”  (Slight pause.)

One of my commentaries on the assigned readings for today says this (quote:) “The season of Lent always brings the church back to the basics, to issues that are bedrock and essential.  It is no time for marginal matters that linger about the periphery, but is for those topics and experiences that lie close to the heartbeat of the faith.”

“The texts of Lent force us to reflect on where we— as communities and as individuals— stand in relation to the center, and then they invite a process of self-examination, repentance, forgiveness and a new life.” [2]  (Slight pause.)

I want to unpack two words in that commentary.  First, the word ‘repentance,’ contrary to populist belief, ‘repentance’ does not mean feeling sorry.  ‘Repentance’ means turning our lives toward God.  Please note: ‘repentance’ does not means turning our lives over to the church, which is only an institution.  ‘Repentance’ is about us and God.

Second, ‘forgiveness’— forgiveness is not primarily about forgiving someone else.  Forgiveness is primarily about forgiving ourselves.  Unless we know how to live with ourselves, we will never discover how to live with others.  Unless we know how to live with ourselves, we will never discover how to live with others.

Having unpacked those words, that brings me back to the basics mentioned in the commentary.  The basic question for us in Lent, the basic question Paul is posing for us in Romans is simple.  Where do we, as communities and as individuals, stand in relation to the center?  Where do we, as communities and as individuals, stand in relation to God?  (Slight pause.)

If we stand as one people— in Paul’s words, if we stand as neither Jew nor Greek— then we stand in a relationship with God and one another.  Are we all friends?  Probably not.  We are all very different with different tastes, different backgrounds and sometimes (dare I say it?) even different sociology.

But we all can and should stand as one people, equal before God.  It is in that way, standing before God as one, that we can truly celebrate our differences and our unity.

I was reminded of that Wednesday night as we gathered for an Ash Wednesday Service.  Pastors and members of the United Church of Christ, the First Baptist Church, Christ Lutheran Church, the Broad Street United Methodist Church and Emmanuel Episcopal Church stood as one before God in worship.

Did we, as we gathered, have differences?  Yes.  It is likely we would agree on everything?  No.  But did we stand as one before God?  Yes.  We worshiped God together, as one.  (Slight pause.)

So, what is the season of Lent about?  It is about who we are and identifying who we are.  It is about recognizing who our neighbor really is and understanding we are not members of separate tribes.

It is about who God is— and when I think about it: God who is, and trying to wrestle with that— who God is and trying to wrestle with that.  It is about standing as one before God and being humble enough to do that.  It is, hence, about a process of self-examination, repentance, forgiveness and a new life.  Amen.

02/17/2013
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York

ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Congregational Response and Benediction.  This is an précis of what was said: “Our thought for meditation in the bulletin today was from Joan D. Chittister, a member of the Benedictine Sisters of Erie, Pennsylvania, an author and a speaker: ‘Lent is not a ‘penitential season.’  Lent is a ‘growing season.’ It is a reminder that we need to see this time of year but perhaps all year as a time when growing in our relationship with God and one another needs to be nurtured.”

BENEDICTION: God heals and restores.  God grants to us the grace and the talent to witness to the love God has for us.  Let us be ready as we go into the world, for we are baptized in the power of the Spirit.  And may the peace of Christ, which surpasses understanding, keep our minds and hearts in the companionship and will of the Holy Spirit, this day and forever more.  Amen.
[1]  Luke 1:1-4, Inclusive Language Version, with the reference to Theophilus omitted.

[2]  Texts for Preaching (the Electronic Version) on the commentary for this Sunday, the First Sunday in Lent, Year ‘C’.

Sunday, February 10, 2013

SERMON ~ 02/10/2013 ~ Seeing But Silent

02/10/2013 ~ Last Sunday Before Lent ~ Known in Some Traditions as the Fifth Sunday after the Epiphany ~ Known in Some Traditions as the Fifth Sunday in Ordinary Time ~ Known in Some Traditions as Transfiguration Sunday ~ Exodus 34:29-35; Psalm 99; 2 Corinthians 3:12-4:2; Luke 9:28-36, (37-43a).

Seeing But Silent


“Then from the cloud came a voice that said, ‘This is my Own, my Chosen; listen!’  When the voice had finished speaking, they saw no one but Jesus standing there.  The disciples kept silent, telling nothing of what they had seen at that time to anyone.” — Luke 9:35-36.

Mary Oliver has won the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize.  The New York Times describes her as (quote): “far and away, America’s best-selling poet.”  Given the snow event which obviously effected others more than us— to be clear, I have no interest in diminishing the trouble it caused for some— but given the snow event which obviously did not effect us as much as it effected others, I thought it appropriate to start my comments with a poem by Mary Oliver.  It is called White Eyes.  (Slight pause.)

In winter / all the singing is in / the tops of the trees / where the wind-bird // with its white eyes / shoves and pushes / among the branches. / Like any of us // he wants to go to sleep, / but he’s restless— / he has an idea, / and slowly it unfolds // from under his beating wings / as long as he stays awake / But his big, round music, after all, / is too breathy to last. // So, it’s over. / In the pine-crown / he makes his nest, / he’s done all he can. // I don’t know the name of this bird, / I only imagine his glittering beak / while the clouds— // which he has summoned / from the north— / which he has taught / to be mild, and silent— // thicken, and begin to fall / into the world below / like stars, or the feathers / of some unimaginable bird // that loves us, / that is asleep now, and silent— / that has turned itself / into snow.  (Slight pause.)

That is certainly a different take on winter weather than snow-mageddon style predictions— some of which are accurate and some of which are not— it is different than the snow-mageddon predictions the media tends to give us these days.  Indeed, what has always impressed me about snow is not the clamor nor the disruption it causes— and it can and sometimes does cause those.

What impresses me about snow is the silence.  You see, I think one hears rain.  But one feels snow.

I remember playing in the snow when I was a child.  I remember building snow castles, snow forts on the streets of Brooklyn, fortified positions from which we threw snowballs at kids across the street or at unsuspecting adults who passed by.  In some ways the point was to make noise.

But all that happened after it had stopped snowing, when the sun was out.  It was the aftermath.  I remember once looking out the window of my house for hours in the depth of night as better than a foot of snow fell gently, softly, silently.

Then, as the snow was not quite finished, I threw on a coat and rushed out the door into the dark of that night, into the middle of what had been just hours earlier a busy street filled with traffic.  Now it was simply a deserted field of snow.  I did a belly flop and pretended I could swim my way to the other side.

But again, I remember the silence of it all.  That, I think— the silence— is what Oliver’s poem captures so well.

I also think we live in a society which likes noise.  Therefore, we turn the silent snow, snow which is meant to be felt not heard, we turn snow into noise before it even happens.  And so, we predict snow-mageddons.  (Slight pause.)

And these words are from the work known as Luke/Acts in the section commonly called Luke: “Then from the cloud came a voice that said, ‘This is my Own, my Chosen; listen!’  When the voice had finished speaking, they saw no one but Jesus standing there.  The disciples kept silent, telling nothing of what they had seen at that time to anyone.”  (Slight pause.)

As was mentioned when today’s readings were introduced, these are both stories of theophanies— theophany— an experience of the real presence of God. [1]  It was also said the Christmas story is a theophany.  Indeed, I think one point we miss as we read Scripture is it’s filled with theophanies— experiences of the real presence of God and descriptions of the experience are repeated over and over.

After all, what else is the Christmas story about but an announcement of the in-breaking of God into our world?  That is a theophany by any definition.

And so, the church goes from the theophany of Christmas into the Season of Epiphany, a season which proclaims the revelation of God by its very name and then ends the season with the story— the specific story— of yet another theophany, the Transfiguration.  It is a way to say this is a prime message found in Scripture.  So Scripture is, indeed, constantly telling us and telling us and telling us yet again that the experience of God is real.

Scripture actually constantly tells us not just that the experience of God is real.  Scripture tells us God is real.  (Slight pause.)

The language we use to tell that story, to tell others about the presence of God, matters not.  The content matters not.  Telling the story with exactness or even artfully is not the point.  The point is to tell the story.

And point of the story?  God is real.  God is present among us.  God is working in our lives.  God is a part of our lives.

Hence, in making the point that God is real, the Transfiguration is one of the more fascinating stories of a theophany in all Scripture.  The way I see it, several things make it so, make it fascinating.  First, the voice of God says: “listen!”

In the era the New Testament was first heard, any Jew would have recognized this word, “listen,” as an echo of the Shema, the great commandment.  “Hear, O Israel, Yahweh, our God, is one.”

This explains an understanding of the early church concerning the person of Jesus.  Jesus is one with God.  Further, this one word— “listen”— underscores the meaning in this passage and declarers there should be no mistake when it comes to understating that meaning.  The story is a theophany.

Second, we have this (quote): “The disciples kept silent, telling nothing of what they had seen at that time to anyone.”  (Slight pause.)  In a telling of the same story but as it is found in another Gospel, Jesus instructs the disciples to keep silent.  In this version Jesus says nothing.

So, in this telling they keep silent on their own.  Why?  Were they overwhelmed?  Did they not understand?  We are not told in the text.

I, myself, like to think the event we call the Transfiguration is both silent and demands silence— there is no noise in the background— it is silent and demands silence— so we can listen.  I also think the voices we hear about in the story are more felt than heard.

So, in that sense, I think this is also true of our own experiences of God.  God is more felt than heard.  We may eventually put words to that experience.  But unless we feel God, we do not hear God and we cannot, then, put our own voice to that experience.

This is one reason our denomination, the United Church of Christ, is on such solid ground in saying “God Is Still Speaking.”  Our claim is that God speaks not because we discern words but because we experience God.  Our claim is that God is real.  Our claim is God is present among us.  God is working in our lives.  God is a part of our lives.  (Pause.)

Arguably the greatest play ever written was Hamlet by William Shakespeare.  Just before Hamlet dies, he makes a request of his best friend, Horatio.  “If thou didst ever hold me in thy heart / Absent thee from felicity awhile, / And in this harsh world draw thy breath in pain, / To tell my story.”  (Sight pause.)

Tell my story.  It is the request of a dying friend to testify to his reality.  And that is where we struggle.  If God is real for us, if God is working in our lives, if God is a part of our lives, if we experience God, can we, do we, tell the story?

To be clear: for those of us reticent to voice what we think about God, how God feels to us, I am not confining telling about our experience of God to mere language.  Actions often do speak louder than words.  And there are many ways to speak.  (Slight pause.)

So, what is a theophany about?  It is about the experience of the real presence of God.  (Slight pause.)  Well, what is your experience of the real presence of God?  And how are you willing to share it in whatever way you are called, in whatever way you can?  Amen.

02/10/2013
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York

ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Congregational Response and Benediction.  This is an précis of what was said: “A pastor friend of mine recently posted on Facebook a cartoon of two people standing in an airport.  One has a “tee shirt” on.  The shirt is emblazoned with the words: ‘Let’s talk about Jesus.’  The caption has the one person saying to the other: ‘I figure this way no one will talk to me for the entire flight.’  But remember, telling the story is not and should not be confined to only to language.  Language might prove to be inadequate.”

BENEDICTION: God heals and restores.  God grants to us the grace and the talent to witness to the love God has for us.  So let us live in the light God offers.  And, therefore, let us be ready as we go into the world, for we are baptized in the power of the Spirit.  And may the peace of Christ, which surpasses understanding, keep our minds and hearts in the companionship and will of the Holy Spirit, this day and forever more.  Amen.

[1]  The readings used were the ones assigned by the Lectionary from Exodus and Luke.

Monday, February 4, 2013

SERMON ~ 02/03/2013 ~ Imperfect Knowledge

02/03/2013 ~ Fourth Sunday after the Epiphany ~ Known in Some Traditions as the Fourth Sunday in Ordinary Time ~ Jeremiah 1:4-10; Psalm 71:1-6; 1 Corinthians 13:1-13; Luke 4:21-30 ~ COMMUNION SUNDAY.

Imperfect Knowledge

“Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things and has the power to endure all things.  Love never ends.” — 1 Corinthians 13:7-8a.

I need to start today’s comments with a question.  (Slight pause.)  What does it meant to be a Christian?  (Slight pause.)

Does being a Christian mean one assents to a set of beliefs or precepts? (Slight pause.)  I’ll come back to that.  (Slight pause.)

I have mentioned dozens of times that my late mother joined a convent— she was a nun— but dropped out of the order before taking her final vows.  I’ve also mentioned my late father taught at a Jesuit High School for the vast majority of his working life.

While it might, therefore, seem like I went into the family business, I think a major effect of this was the friendships I made.  You see, clergy— especially Jesuits— were my friends when I was growing up.  Indeed, I remember when I was 18 or 19 a Jesuit friend invited me and a couple of my friends to dinner at a rectory in Greenwich Village to meet a friend of his.

That friend was the activist, Philip Berrigan.  Philip and his more famous brother Dan got on the FBI 10 most wanted list for involvement with the peace movement.

They were both prosecuted for being among the so called Catonsville Nine and the so called Baltimore Four.  One James Mengel, a U.C.C. pastor, was a part of the Baltimore Four.  Perhaps my background is closer to home than it might seem on the surface.  (Slight pause.)

So, what does it meant to be a Christian?  Does it mean one assents to a set of beliefs?  (Slight pause.)

Recent polls say 20 percent of Americans make a claim to be “spiritual but not religious.”  Reverend Lillian Daniel, pastor of the First Congregational Church in Glen Ellyn, a Chicago suburb, has published a book on the topic.  This the title: When “Spiritual But Not Religious” Is Not Enough: Seeing God in Surprising Places, Even the Church.

People tell you they find God in sunsets, she says, but anyone can find God in a sunset.  Finding God in the flawed human community and in a tradition bigger than you with people who may not reflect God back to you in your own image— that’s remarkable.

An equal opportunity critic, Daniel also levels criticism at church members, like those who say a quarterback has been blessed by God for scoring a winning touchdown.  Surely Christians are praying just as hard on other football teams.  Did God ignore them?  Or did they just pray the wrong way?

There are also Christians who do disgusting things like burn copies of the Qur’an.  These behaviors should be an embarrassment to people of faith, says Daniel.  (Slight pause.)

What does it meant to be a Christian?  Does it mean one assents to a set of beliefs?  (Slight pause.)

A colleague recently said when the Nicene Creed was issued— and in some ways the Nicene Creed is a list of beliefs— when the Nicene Creed was issued, that started the downfall Christianity.  People assented to that list, said my friend, and it was the beginning of the end for Christianity.

I suggested that is not at all what happened at the Council of Nicaea.  You see, thinking of the Creed as a list of beliefs did not happen until about thirteen centuries after it was written— around the time of the Enlightenment.  So, what did the Creed mean when it was written if it is not a list of beliefs?

The Latin word we translate as ‘I believe,’ credo, does not mean a list of intellectual beliefs.  Credo means something to which I give my heart.  (Slight pause.)

Another colleague recently said he wished the age of dogma would give way to the age of dialogue, discussion.  Discussion, after all, rests on mutual respect for diverse opinions and those who hold them.  Discussion means reserving the right to be wrong.

However, we live in an era when opinions do not seem to allow for space or allow for respect.  Positions taken are the end of discussion.  And facts are ignored when they do not conform to opinion.  There are some who even like this world of easy absolutes, a world which permits no nuance, no compromise, no differences, a world of dogma.  (Slight pause.)

So, what does it meant to be a Christian?  Does it mean one assents to a set of beliefs?  And are those beliefs narrow?  (Slight pause.)

Now, there is a difference between dogma and doctrine.  Dogma is either what you decide you will believe and that you will allow for nothing else and/or Dogma is what someone else decides will be believed and you buy into it, allowing for nothing else.

Doctrine, on the other hand, is an explanation of belief.  Therefore, doctrine relates back to the Latin credo.  Doctrine is something to which we might give our heart, something we can love, especially since it is our explanation.

And I think, for Paul, not belief but love is the prime issue.  That is because, for Paul, what we believe is encompassed by and in a relationship with God.  So, he talks about love.  And love is not about a list of beliefs.

Indeed, how does Paul talk about love?  By making the obvious argument: knowledge is imperfect.  Or, in modern terms, why do we insult someone when we say they are a ‘Know It All?’  We inherently recognize, as did Paul, that knowledge is imperfect, incomplete.

But Paul’s position also states that, because knowledge is imperfect, incomplete, so too it is with love.  Love is imperfect, incomplete, flawed.

But, having said that, Paul also insists love can be perfect, can be complete.  How?  Again, in today’s terms, what Paul says is that we humans are and need to see ourselves as beings of sacred worth— beings of sacred worth.

If we see ourselves beings of sacred worth, then love can be imperfect even as we seek the perfect.  How?  God, who is perfect, loves us.  God sees us as beings of sacred worth, despite imperfection, despite our flaws.  And God wants to be in covenant with us.

Indeed, this is how Paul restates the ancient covenant God has made with humanity (quote):  “Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things and has the power to endure all things.  Love never ends.”  (Slight pause.)

So, what does it meant to be a Christian?  Does it mean one assents to a set of beliefs?  No.  It means one assents to love.  Amen.

02/03/2013
United Church of Christ, First Congregational, Norwich, New York

ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Congregational Response and Benediction.  This is an précis of what was said: “There is a story that goes around about a fairly local personality, Carl Sagan.  He lived just over in Ithaca.  The story may well be apocryphal, but it’s the story that goes around.  He was a fairly well known agnostic and he and a colleague were in a discussion and he offered all kind of proof to his colleague that God did not exist.  And then his colleague said, ‘So, Carol, does love exist?’  And he because a little flustered.  His colleague said, ‘Can’t prove that, either, can you?’”

BENEDICTION: Through God’s grace, by being attentive to God’s will, our deeds and our words will change our world for we will discover ways to proclaim release from the bondage of narrowness.  Let us seek the God of Joy whose wisdom is our God.   Let us go in peace to love and serve God.  Amen.